I guess I fail the test. I always preferred crunchy and DW wanted smooth. Of course, with a peanut-allergic DS we haven't had it in the house in years, so we both forgot what it tastes like.
I went on a week-long business trip a while back and didn't eat out the whole week. I bought a jar of PB, a jar of jelly, and a loaf of bread on the way to the hotel and ate PB&J in the room every night. Delicious!