since I'm the one who led us down this path ... here's how we got to where we are
right now (and I say right now, since our situation is still evolving

)
DS is in top 15% of his class, his class rank is in the upper teens out of a class of 150. He is not NMSF/F, nor did he participate in our state's Governors Scholars Program. He applied to 6 schools, all located in our home state of Kentucky: 2 private, liberal arts schools and 4 state schools, including our flagship school, the University of Kentucky.
Being admitted was not a concern with his GPA/ACT score. Accepted at all 6, into honors program at 3 of the 4 state schools. He is waiting to hear about the University of Kentucky honors program, but that one is going to be a
long shot, I'm afraid.
He is still strongly considering 4 of the 6 schools he applied to. School #5 may come back into play, depending on scholarship/aid package. School #6 is completely off the table.
He applied/interviewed for major scholarship programs at 4 of the 5 schools on the list. Have heard from 3 so far -- not under consideration for any of the 3. Particularly disappointing was not being invited to interview for the Presidential Fellowship at the school where he participated in an honors program last summer. Adding insult to injury, two of the rejection letters came within 3 days of each other. Ouch.
As of today, he has one generous scholarship offer from a state school. (auto award with his GPA/ACT) We will likely make a visit there over spring break.
Scholarship/Financial Aid offers from the others schools will come within the next few weeks. I have no idea what to expect from any of these offers ... hopefully they'll be strong, in spite of DS not being considered for the major awards. Accept/reject letters from the UK Honors College should arrive by Friday. Again, expectations are realistic for that. LOL