Definitely Paradise Pier if it's the same price! I really love the PPH. I was just there a couple of weeks ago, and, while I didn't have a concierge room, I've heard great things about the PPH concierge. I did, however, get a free upgrade to a park view room and had an awesome view of DCA, complete with World of Color and audible bloodcurdling screams from Mickey's Wheel of Death. Plus, you can't beat the Mickey ears bath products in the rooms, and the overall spaciousness.