What would be cool is if they could rotate which rides they do every year. For example on the odd years (2009, 2011, 2013 etc etc..) do the Haunted Mansion and Story book canal overlays. Then on the even years (2010, 2012 etc...) do an overlay for Splash Mountain and Its a Small World.
I like traveling mostly between Oct and December and I can't remember the last time I have seen the Haunted Mansion without the Nightmarish overlay.
Great idea, Sy! Because, realistically, it is a lot of work for them to revamp those rides, and it takes two weeks to do it for each ride - in fact, IASW would be re-opening two weeks earlier this year if not for the holiday re-do - and they just wouldn't be able to keep adding more Christmas versions of rides on top of the existing ones, because half the park would be shut down! I mean, let's be honest here - I would LOVE it and would accept a two-week shut down of the park IF they re-did ALL the rides in holiday motif. Wouldn't that be awesome - to go to
Disneyland during the holidays and not only get all the regular benefits of being there during that time but also getting all totally redone rides? That would be amazing, if they could transform the park, literally, from the inside out! So much work, though.
But back to reality. Sy's idea is fantastic. Rotate the holiday rides. HM and IASW are kind of spectacles. They are moving 'shows,' almost. Not just rides, but songs and overall spectacles. Storybookland may have had some little decorations here and there, but Disney obviously did not go all out 100% with it or they would have advertised it as 'Storybookland Holiday.' So it couldn't have been a totally redecorated ride. They probably just stuck in a few ornaments. Then again, even if they DID totally deck it out with fake snow and different Christmas scenes, it STILL would not be the 'spectacles' that HM and IASW are. Splash Mountain would be a good Christmas fit. I am still on the fence about Pirates. I just don't think that would work. I think Tiki Room would be perfect. I think they could do something interesting with Alice in Wonderland and they could really decorate Tom Sawyer's Island to make that a little mini-holiday village.
But whatever they do, rotating is excellent because then, each year, you would know you were getting something different. And after seeing HM in its holiday version, I am almost NOT as interested in riding it when it is in 'regular' form! You just cannot top that, but if they did it year round, it wouldn't be as special anymore!