Thanks for the ideas! Its nice to meet someone so "local".
Bar Harbor is a great idea...however, we go there for a conference for work every year, and the family tags along. The office pays for 1/2 my room, so its a really inexpensive getaway for us...especially factoring in I only have conferences till noon, so the rest of the day is ours.
We have done Storyland and Santa's Village the last few years, so I am looking for a change...btw, have you ever done Santa's at Christmastime? We talk about it every year, and never make it.
PA is a big possibility...we had planned to do it last year, and it didn't work out. They had some awesome looking farm B & B's that I wanted to try...
We did Lake George one year, and to be honest, I wasn't impressed. It reminded me of Old Orchard Beach
The Poconos had never occured to me...maybe because that's where DH honeymooned with his first wife

But its a really good idea...I will check that out!