OT: CBC TV/ who's your favourite Maria?

[Northstar]

So is anybody watching How Do You Solve a Problem Like Maria?

We're glued to the tube... something about Sound of Music, Andrew Lloyd Webber, and the gruesome Survivor/talent-show aspect of the competition.

Who's your favourite Maria? My family is divided between Janna (best performance last night) and Kyla (hometown girl, and we think she was shafted by their choice for her song last night)

 

[mickeywho?]

I watched it for the first time last night - really enjoyed it! My favourite last night was (I don't know any names sorry!) the performance from Wicked - thought it was great - although I'm not sure if I can see her as Maria. The one I would have chosen as Maria from the performances last night was the cute girl in the green dress that did a song from Guys and Dolls. Very well done. A surprisingly good summer fill-in show from CBC - who da thunk it?!

 

[bbangel]

I'm a Janna fan! I do sometimes question the song and wardrobe choices for some of the girls. Very fun to watch and will be interesting to see the outcome.

 

[CJ]

I thought Jamie was very good last night.... it was my first time watching the show. The judges are TOUGH!!!

 

[nflder]

Jayme for me - at least this week. I've been watching since the beginning and each week I change who I like. I like Janna - but can't see her as Maria. Personally - I would love to see Julie Andrews!!! But alas that will not happen.

 

[snickerboo]

Jayme is my favourite Maria. I was surprised the judges didn't comment that she hiked up her dress when it strated to fall down, though! LOL I think Janna is very talented but I can't see her as Maria. Janna's performance last night was excellent but the singing was very shouty.

 

[Lollipop's Mom]

Janna and Elisha are the faves at our house. I hated the previous 2 episodes with them singing pop songs. Its impossible to judge them when they are singing bad renditions of Avril!

 

[pxlbarrel]

I was at last week's taping of the performance show and the results show. Pretty fun stuff. If you get a chance to get tickets, you should try.

My favourite is Donna although she doesn't fit the body type of a Maria, I think she sings fabulously.

 

[CJ]

My VCR taped the wrong channel tonight!

Can anyone tell me which two went home and what they sang last night?

thanks

 

[pxlbarrel]

My VCR taped the wrong channel tonight!

Can anyone tell me which two went home and what they sang last night?

thanks

The three who sang were Kyla, Tamara and Katie. They sang Jesus Christ Superstar. Simon saved Tamara. Kyla and Katie are going home.

 

[CJ]

The three who sang were Kyla, Tamara and Katie. They sang Jesus Christ Superstar. Simon saved Tamara. Kyla and Katie are going home.

Thanks! Do you remember what Kyla & Katie sang last night (it was my first time watching and I don't know all their names yet, but I can remember based on the song).

I know I really liked Jayme & Elisa!

 

[pxlbarrel]

Thanks! Do you remember what Kyla & Katie sang last night (it was my first time watching and I don't know all their names yet, but I can remember based on the song).

I know I really liked Jayme & Elisa!

Hmmm... Katie sang something from Hair but it was a song I wasn't familiar with. The only reason I know it was from Hair was that John Barrowman said that he had performed in Hair and that Katie's performance was lacking. Kyla...I think but not sure, performed All That Jazz from Chicago. There was a lot of dancing in her number and by the end of it, you could tell she was winded. Simon called her on that.

I think that's what Kyla sang. I have to admit that there are a few of the girls who have the same hair colour, length of hair etc and I can't tell them apart.

 

[DearDaisyinDurham]

I was at last week's taping of the performance show and the results show. Pretty fun stuff. If you get a chance to get tickets, you should try.

My favourite is Donna although she doesn't fit the body type of a Maria, I think she sings fabulously.

We're also cheering for Donna. What fun to go watch the show!!!!!

 

[JohnMouse]

I saw the CBC site for this Maria show. Too bad I don't live near the border! Janna seems to be the favorite contestant, according to the unofficial fan poll. I saw her picture and I think she looks a little like "Carey" from Zack and Cody. I think Jayme looks like Ariel a little.

 

[pxlbarrel]

Jayme is my favourite Maria. I was surprised the judges didn't comment that she hiked up her dress when it strated to fall down, though! LOL I think Janna is very talented but I can't see her as Maria. Janna's performance last night was excellent but the singing was very shouty.

Re Janna shouty singing... I think a lot has to do with the song she sang. "Defying Gravity" isn't a soft spoken song and pretty much is shouty. LOL I think the choice of song makes a HUGE difference in how the Canadian voting public votes. And I know that they've been given certain songs to do so that they can showcase different aspects of their singing (ie, Donna was given the rather passive song from Oklahoma but it was show us she could sing as a soprano which she hasn't done in the past.) But...if you're given a dud of a song ... like whoever got the song from the Evita movie last night...you can be sunk.

 

[DearDaisyinDurham]

Re Janna shouty singing... I think a lot has to do with the song she sang. "Defying Gravity" isn't a soft spoken song and pretty much is shouty. LOL I think the choice of song makes a HUGE difference in how the Canadian voting public votes. And I know that they've been given certain songs to do so that they can showcase different aspects of their singing (ie, Donna was given the rather passive song from Oklahoma but it was show us she could sing as a soprano which she hasn't done in the past.) But...if you're given a dud of a song ... like whoever got the song from the Evita movie last night...you can be sunk.

They don't get to choose their song? I agree, that makes a huge difference.
Song choice, performance, personality, costumes, even your expression as you sing, the viewers are looking at everything!

If you also watch Canadian Idol, please vote in my poll.

 

[Northstar]

Well, one of our favourites - Kyla from Dartmouth, NS - is gone. She didn't have a good performance last Sunday, though I didn't think it was bad. But there is such hot competition! Those women can sing. Makes a great show.

I do think the choice of song can influence the voting, to a degree where they are really engineering the show/voting to get rid of the ones they have decided should be cut... just like in a normal audition, I guess, so it's not evil or anything, just that it seems they're trying to over-play the audience choice aspect of it.

And did you notice how all the women who had a lot of dance moves to do in their numbers had poor vocal performances last Sunday? Now if Maria was a really dance-intensive role, that would make sense to see if they can sing and dance at the same time... but then they should all have to do it. A level playing field!

 

[suprgrlx]

I was at last week's taping of the performance show and the results show. Pretty fun stuff. If you get a chance to get tickets, you should try.

My favourite is Donna although she doesn't fit the body type of a Maria, I think she sings fabulously.

We get to go this Sunday! I'm very excited.

Based on this week's performance, I really liked Marisa. I also liked Jayme and thought that Elicia did a fantastic job (though I usually don't like that song). I found that Donna was underwhelming this week (though I usually like her too), and I really didn't like Tamara's performance. It seems like Janna is really the favourite, but honestly (and I feel bad about this) I can't watch her and not think about Celine Dion, and I found the costume/wind-machine made that even worse this week. Oh well.

Overall, I'm really enjoying the show, even if it seems like it's going very fast (two people gone next week too I think).

 

[CJ]

And isn't it great to watch a reality show that isn't a remake of an American one? (no offense intended at all here, but Canadian Idol is just soooooo lame!)

 

[suprgrlx]

And isn't it great to watch a reality show that isn't a remake of an American one? (no offense intended at all here, but Canadian Idol is just soooooo lame!)

I tend to agree, but I got the impression this was a remake of the British show. Based on the wiki article, the BBC did three versions for three different musicals.