Opinions on Mama Melrose's

DH and I ate there on our honeymoon and did not like it.....the service was extremely slow.....and the place was empty....the food was ok, but Olive Garden is way better....it's one we will definately NOT do again.
 
Our family thought MM's was wonderful. We started with a phenomenal salad that had balsamic vinaigrette and hidden pieces of gorgonzola! Yum! This was extremely fresh and delicious. Also, Dh and I had the steak with polenta which was out of this world! For dessert, I had tiramisu and Dh had cheesecake (I think). No complaints from this place which was hopping in May when we went as part of the Fantasmic dinner package.
Remember, that every restaurant receives a bad report now and then. They have lots of us to please. If MM's menu sounds like something you might like--try it. I'm a firm believer in if it's a place you really want to try or think you might like, give it a go.
 
We always do the fantasmic package here and we love it. We do stick with the steak though and it is very tender. I also agree that the salad was delicious.
 

We love to eat at MM. I always get the chicken flatbread and a caesar salad, yummy!!! Fun atmosphere, too.
 
and the table service was horrible, the food was horrible... We had the Fantasmic package, it rained that night and it was cancelled ( we caught Fantasmic on another night, Great Seats BTW!!!)... We caught Fantasmic on Wednesday night (11/29) got into the show around 6:30pm Fantasmic was @ 7pm) Never Again will I do the package. Mama Melrose's for 7 people was $250. The food was awful, my husand got the Spicy Sausage and pasta and it was Burned. DD (17) got the veal osso bucco, it was barely a mouth full of meat. All in all, the food was NOT worth it. We did eat at Mama Melrose's about 6 years ago NOT on the Fantasmic Package and it was Great. Not sure if that makes a difference.

Hope that helps.


PS We had ADR 's for 4:20 pm and Fantasmic was at 7Pm On 11/28 we almost didn't make it, we had to hurry the waitress along and she gave us a hard time on a discount for our DDE for the alchohol which ISn't on the package.
 
We love it, done the fantasmic package several times and its one of our favorite places to eat!!
 
I hated everything about it - sorry!The food was lousy and so was the service. It is one restaurant I will not be going back to.

Maggs
 
maggs said:
I hated everything about it - sorry!The food was lousy and so was the service. It is one restaurant I will not be going back to.

Maggs

We also did not like it and will not go back ever again. We had the Fantasmic package and wanted something a little mor intimate but next time that we think the Fantasmic package is necessary we will go to the buffet at H&V.
 
Our family likes it a whole lot. The food is good and it's a nice break from the hustle and bustle outside. I agree with cmj2003, everyone's taste is different. Every restaurant is Disney gets good/bad/ugly/ok/wonderful ratings from someone on these boards. If the menu sounds good to you, give it a try!
 
My fiance & I thought it was real good food. The service was ok, but other than that yummy :dog2: !
 
We loved it!!! The food was good, loved the salad and garlic bread. My dessert was yummy, some sort of warm chocolate cake (in a circle) with oozy chocolate sauce in the middle, YUM! WE did the Fantasmic package and thought that with the dining plan and only 1 credit this was a STEAL. We are doing this again this summer.

Lesley
 
had the free dining package in Oct. and used it to reserve Fantasmic package w/dinner @ Mama Melrose. The service was great, but the food was dismal. Would never pay to eat here, would not even go for free, just my .02
 
We didn't care for it at all and we'll probably never go back. The atmosphere was charming, but we thought the food was pretty lousy. I had ordered the chicken flatbread, having heard good things here on the DIS, and I didn't care for it at all. Our service was fine, it was just the poor quality of the food.

At MGM we liked 50's Prime Time a thousand times better. Good luck! ::MinnieMo
 
We have been there for both lunch and dinner, but have never had the fantasmic package there, and really enjoyed our meals, the food was good and plentyful, the service was fine, it was a nice break in a hot day at MGM. We have reservation for the next time we go.
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom