We were thinking of trying Cap'n Jack's on our next trip.
It would be DS2, DD5, DS9 and six adults (on the dining plan)
Any opinions on food? atmosphere?
Nowhere near as good as it was 20-30 years ago. Boy I feel old now. The atmosphere is great the menu is limited and the food quality is fair. There are better restaurants at DTD but like I always say if you think you'd like give it a try. Just because some other people didn't care for it doesn't mean you wont. We still eat there once in a while.