One time ECV experience - off-putting HM and restaurant interactions - is this typical??

olive

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 15, 2008
Messages
844
I have appreciated the advice in my thread about travel to WDW with two prosthetics - I think it made for a more successful trip for my father. We just returned, and halfway through the trip, I had to join him in renting an ECV after breaking a bone in my foot at the Poly and being advised at the ER not to walk for the rest of the vacation. At least I was in an area where wheelchairs are readily available, as the dr at Celebration hospital pointed out.

I rented from Buena Vista based mostly on availability. They were also very nice on the phone. I was there during a rainy period, including the Erika effects, and with the big warning tag on the ECV I tried to keep as much of the electronics on the ECV covered as possible and also parked it inside where available. It was generally not parked outside in the rain that I can think of.

I had an issue though on our last evening when I tried to ride HM with my son. I was diverted down a hallway with him because of the ECV. We waited for a bit, and then I was asked to park in a hallway. I did so, and then two more folks with ECVs came up behind me and the ride CM appeared. He asked if I could walk a short distance. I could hobble briefly at this point, but it had only been a few days since the fracture and I could not walk any significant distance. I said a short distance was okay. He then asked me and the others to follow him (I assume but don't know if he asked them the same question). He proceeded to lead us outside the exit of HM and asked us to park outside against the wall, entirely exposed to the elements. Now this was a night of such torrential rain that both the electrical parade and Wishes were cancelled. Many rides were closed. I was concerned about the ECV getting soaked, and it was very far from the entrance to the ride. I asked why we were being asked to park outside, especially in light of the weather. There were several ECVs parked inside in the hall. I was told that parking inside was a hazard, which was confusing since I was first asked to park inside and there were other ECVs lined up inside. I mentioned the weather (the tag on the ECV warned about it getting wet, and the weather was no little drizzle - again, the parade and fireworks were cancelled and many attractions were closed; these were serious downpours). I expressed a concern about being stranded if something shorted since the electronics could not get wet and I only had a plastic bag for protection; there was absolutely no way I could make it out of the park on my own two feet. Two people behind me also piped up (a husband and wife, I believe) about not wanting to park outside. They were highly resistant. I am not sure if they had personal ECVs - not sure if different models may be more sensitive. In any event, a second CM seemed to be challenging why I even was trying to ride the attraction if it was so difficult (I suppose because of the mobility issue) - which I found very off putting. I had been able to ride many rides with my children since the accident, just riding through queues or parking close by and waking very short distances. I explained that my son wanted to ride and it was our last night, and that I understood there was an accommodation for people with mobility issues and I didn't seem to be getting any accommodation here to meet my need. She said something to the effect of parking outside and walking 300 feet would meet that need. 300 feet! That was the first I heard of that, and I said so. I thought it seem far, but for all I knew there was a door I hadn't noticed and you got right on. I explained that I could not walk anything near that distance and if I had been asked if I could walk that far I would have said absolutely not. Apparently by "short distance" they meant "200-300 feet." I was told then that the ECVs parked inside were for people who could not walk more than 15 feet. (What happens then to the people who can walk 16 feet but not 200? This was odd to me.) I felt the whole situation was aggressive and did not like being challenged for wanting to ride HM, which is perhaps my favorite ride at Disney. The other couple and I shared some observations about the situation. The CMs just seemed angry and more interested in trying to keep our ECVs outside than meeting needs. I was actually saddened by this.

At San Angel Inn, I was able to park my ECV by the restaurant entrance and transfer to a chair at our table. My father cannot do this, however, and when I made the reservation months out I asked if a wheelchair could be accommodated since he can't transfer. I was told yes. The receipt we received at check in noted the wheelchair accommodation request. Yet the restaurant wasn't prepared with a table that could fit the ECV. So fine, we waited a bit; they had already led us to the table so we tried to stay out of the way while the manager made jokes about musical chairs and more than once mentioned that "this was the first he was hearing of this" (the ECV accommodation). We are then presented with the table again with two chairs hanging off the end, without table space, and expected to be grateful. I said that wouldn't work, could they find a table that would fit all of the diners? He again repeats that this is the first he is hearing about the wheelchair and he is going to need me to be more patient. At this point it has been quite awhile since we got to the table, and I would have been plenty patient if it weren't constantly insinuated that we were an imposition on his evening. We provided advance notice to try to avoid this and I thought the response was unprofessional. We have been eating at this restaurant since the 80s - including with an ECV - and have never experienced anything like this. I did respond that I was trying to remain patient but losing that patience. Perhaps I should not have, but my demeanor remained calm at all times. Eventually they tacked on another table to lengthen ours and we were able to sit and order. The rest of the meal was fine and once the manager asked if everything was okay. Still, this left a bad taste for me. I don't know what else we could have done to prepare the restaurant - beside mentioning the accommodation when making the original reservation, it was reconfirmed upon check in.

Both of these were uncomfortable situations. I know Disney isn't utopia but I have considered its efforts to accommodate various needs without making people feel uncomfortable a strength. I just did not feel like that was accomplished in these situations. In both we felt decidedly uncomfortable. I didn't complain to Disney or anything, just wondering how to avoid issues like this again. We will be at HM again with my dad, and will possibly return to San Angel. It is a family tradition to dine there, even though this last visit wasn't so successful in a sense. We did still like our food! Maybe the manager was just a bit green.
 
To be fair a wheelchair takes up less room than a scooter. I know I use both. A wheelchair you just pull in the spot of a chair. A scooter takes more space because you need to park side ways and swivel the chair. So If the place was full this can be an issue. That said many seem to be confused between what a scooter and a power wheelchair is. They call many power wheelchairs scooters for some reason. So even if you did tell them they still might not understood. Also many cast members do not seem to understand that people who can only walk a short 20 feet use scooters. They seem to get so used to those who can walk normally but use the scooter for distance or leg issues that constant walking could cause extreme pain. They forget about the fact that there are people who need them for shorter distances than 300 feet. So sorry you had issues. I have had many issues regarding using my scooter. Once I got a power wheelchair I had less. Should not be that way but it seems it is.
 
No experience with your specific experience, but I've had nothing but problems with CM's at the Haunted Mansion regarding disability and accommodations. Bad enough to not get the accommodation you need when you see that others do, but they were uniformly rude and nasty about it in all their interactions. I've only ever encountered one CM at the Mansion who didn't treat me like a piece of garbage. I'm sure others have had a different experience, and I'm sure they'll be quick to say that because they did, it negates mine. But I've talked to plenty of other PWD who have been treated the same way. I don;t know what it is about that attraction - maybe it's just so stressful to operate that any deviation from the norm, no matter how small, becomes a crisis for them, or maybe because they don;t have the same mandate to seem cheerful all the time that CM's elsewhere in the parks do, they feel free to take it too far the other way.

It was my favorite attraction before I had serious medical issues, but the CM's there sure don't make it easy for it to stay that way now.
 
Belle - I don't know if my parents might get a power chair in addition to the scooter they have for home use (they rented the scooter at WDW), but how is it in terms of maneuverability and portability compared to a scooter? I assume their are a variety of models, but possibly this is something that could cut down on similar issues in the future since the power chairs are more compact, and perhaps they could travel with one?

ttintagel - I really did have a hard time enjoying that ride after the rough treatment by the CMs! How odd that giving people with mobility needs a hard time is somewhat common at that attraction. I have to say, using a scooter on this trip was like getting to use an invisibility cloak. I have never felt so ignored while right in front of people - from other patrons there is not much we can expect (like when I would attempt to enter a line and entire families would stream past, even knocking into the chair - or once my fracture boot! - to get in front of me), but I did have some expectations from the ride CMs. I sorry that you have been in the same sort of boat.
 

...I have to say, using a scooter on this trip was like getting to use an invisibility cloak. I have never felt so ignored while right in front of people - from other patrons there is not much we can expect (like when I would attempt to enter a line and entire families would stream past, even knocking into the chair - or once my fracture boot! - to get in front of me), but I did have some expectations from the ride CMs.

Haunted Mansion is a difficult ride - from everyone's perspective. It is a wildly popular ride, and the moving walkway can create challenges for mobility impaired Guests. As you noticed, there is limited space inside to park ECVs - especially the larger park rental models. Many people aren't aware of this, but I find that it's actually far more HA "friendly" than it used to be.

Until it's needed, most folks are quite unaware of how to deal with a mobility impairment at WDW - or anywhere. You obviously are more experienced because you have been involved with your parents issues, so you are more aware of what you expect to see and experience.

What you experienced - people walking into you, bumping you, etc. - is actually quite common at WDW (and yes, places outside of WDW as well) People are so very self-absorbed that they simply aren't paying attention. You aren't even on their radar. The vast majority of people at WDW are too busy taking selfies, posting their lunch to Instagram, and trying to score another FP+ for 7DMT.

i'm not saying that your outrage isn't justified. But you need to understand that your experiences, as uncomfortable and unhappy as they were, are part and parcel of being mobility impaired. Like so many others here, I live with that sort of thing every. single, day. Every day, I consciously choose to assume positive intent on the part of the people I encounter. Occasionally, I do encounter someone who is simply looking to spread their own personal brand of misery around. But for the most part, people are just self-absorbed and clueless.

I know what you are going to say. You are going to say that we must change this. That it's not fair. That the disabled (whether they are temporarily or permanently disabled) have rights. And, you are correct on all counts. But what you must remember is that things ARE better than they were, not so very long ago. They aren't perfect, obviously, but they *are* better. And "fair" is a relative, subjective term - what might be "fair" to one person means someone else's toes will quite possibly be stepped on, literally or figuratively. And as for rights... All I can tell you is that WDW is, far and away, the easiest place in the world to be differently-abled. People - in this case, multiple CMs over the course of your trip - made mistakes. And whenever humans are involved, mistakes are a possibility, because none of us are perfect, least of all me. :)

Try and find those beautiful, shining moments of joy with your parents, and treasure them, and discard the "bad" stuff. Don't let someone else's issue cloud the wonderful memories you just made with your family.

I truly hope that you are on the mend, and that you will soon find yourself back in the ranks of the full-time walking! :)
 
From a CM Viewpoint.
1) There has been a massive increase in the use of ECV's, wheelchairs and strollers
2) This has created a major safety hazard when parking these at attractions and inside eateries.
3) So, CM's do their best at getting the parked vehicles out of the way.
4) With the increase of vehicles, these also has been an increase in people who really don't need them.
. . . many people just do not want to walk (or have their kids walk), so they rent a mobility device
. . . many people hope using the device/vehicle will get them into a ride quicker by avoiding lines
. . . CM's don't know whom to believe when the guest says, they "can't walk"

NOTE: I am not trying to justify the CM's treatment of you or his/her wording. Just trying to explain how these things can happen. Alas, we are all human and sometimes phrase things is less than the best manner.
 
Last edited:
At San Angel Inn, I was able to park my ECV by the restaurant entrance and transfer to a chair at our table. My father cannot do this, however, and when I made the reservation months out I asked if a wheelchair could be accommodated since he can't transfer. I was told yes. The receipt we received at check in noted the wheelchair accommodation request. Yet the restaurant wasn't prepared with a table that could fit the ECV. So fine, we waited a bit; they had already led us to the table so we tried to stay out of the way while the manager made jokes about musical chairs and more than once mentioned that "this was the first he was hearing of this" (the ECV accommodation). We are then presented with the table again with two chairs hanging off the end, without table space, and expected to be grateful. I said that wouldn't work, could they find a table that would fit all of the diners? He again repeats that this is the first he is hearing about the wheelchair and he is going to need me to be more patient. At this point it has been quite awhile since we got to the table, and I would have been plenty patient if it weren't constantly insinuated that we were an imposition on his evening. We provided advance notice to try to avoid this and I thought the response was unprofessional. We have been eating at this restaurant since the 80s - including with an ECV - and have never experienced anything like this. I did respond that I was trying to remain patient but losing that patience. Perhaps I should not have, but my demeanor remained calm at all times. Eventually they tacked on another table to lengthen ours and we were able to sit and order. The rest of the meal was fine and once the manager asked if everything was okay. Still, this left a bad taste for me. I don't know what else we could have done to prepare the restaurant - beside mentioning the accommodation when making the original reservation, it was reconfirmed upon check in.

Perhaps they were confused because you asked about a wheelchair and showed up with an ECV? Also, ADRs are not true 'reservations' they are just a queue system used to help WDW get people to tables more quickly. There was no way for them to have a table that had space for a wheelchair (never mind a much larger ECV) held for you until you showed up. When a table for the size of your party opened up, and it was deemed not accessible, then you'd need to wait until another one opened up, etc. Glad they were able to accommodate your group. Next time you should ask about space for an ECV, not a wheelchair though? That might help them out a lot.
 
Hmmmmm. (no pun intended) Let's see. When you were being led out of Haunted Mansion, what if at some point quite soon you told the CM you can't walk that far back. And then started to go back the other way?

How is HM rated in terms of accessibility? (Maps have used symbols such as wheelchair arrow regular chair to indicate the need to get out of a wheelchair.) A few rides at Magic Kingdom are still officially not accessible.

And "far" is a relative, subjective term - what might be "far" to one person means ...
(pun was intended here) However a 200 foot walk is excessive. Would the CM take the wheelchair at the point of boarding and return it at the ride exit, playing the part of a parking valet?

CM's don't know whom to believe when the guest says, they "can't walk"
The CM must believe the guest." And let the guest change his mind at any time. The guest should feel free to use the words "I can't." The guest should not use the words "I'll try," which words (OT) incidentally should not be used by a professional at work.

Eventually they tacked on another table
That was the correct thing to do. We will have to give the CMs the benefit of the doubt that an extra table section might not have been immediately available but should have been taken as soon as any other party finished dinner and upped and left.
 
Last edited:
Sorry for the delay - my email alerts were down.

At San Angel, waiting for a modifIcation to the table was not specifically a problem, though we had waited quite awhile after confirming at the reservations desk that my father couldn't transfer before being led to the too-small table. (The table added to ours was an empty adjacent one, but I don't know what kind of juggling was required with reservations to make that happen.) It was the repeated statement that "this was the first I heard" about the wheelchair when I had mentioned it in advance - when making the initial reservation and again at check in quite a while before we were seated - rather than just working to find a solution. Making us feel badly for something that we could not change was not appropriate in my mind. Even if this person was surprised for whatever reason, his treatment struck me as unprofessional. We were simply trying to stay out of their way and taking amongst ourselves while it was initially being handled.

At HM, I had a pretty serious fracture boot on so in addition to the ECV there was another "visible" sign of a mobility issue, though of course as a previous poster pointed out I agree that the CMs shouldn't be in the business of doubting a person's stated mobility needs. Having never loaded this way before, I had no idea where we were going, so I didn't realize the distance at first. The experience was an eye opener, though. As for folks who may fake a disability to use an ECV and try to access shorter waits, that is egregious behavior and they may be in for a surprise. I think I often had longer waits with the ECV, though I am sure that varies by attraction, CMs, time of year, etc. I did see children racing ECVs in Epcot which was infuriating.

I appreciate the feedback, as even though I will hopefully be able to avoid using an ECV at the parks in the future, my father will not unless he switched to a power chair. I did ask him about that based on the comments above and so far he said he did not prefer those after testing them out, but I don't have more detail.
 
We just returned from WDW with my son and dil - my dil broke her foot and was in a cast, however was told to put no weight on it at all. We had a scooter for her. At HM, we were told we had to transfer her to a wheelchair and then she had to walk maybe 50 feet to get on the ride. When we were exiting the ride, we saw a number of scooters parked in the exit hallway. So was the first cm incorrect about having to transfer to the wheelchair? It wasn't a huge issue for us, since the weather was good at the time but maybe the cm's should be better trained.
 
We just returned from WDW with my son and dil - my dil broke her foot and was in a cast, however was told to put no weight on it at all. We had a scooter for her. At HM, we were told we had to transfer her to a wheelchair and then she had to walk maybe 50 feet to get on the ride. When we were exiting the ride, we saw a number of scooters parked in the exit hallway. So was the first cm incorrect about having to transfer to the wheelchair? It wasn't a huge issue for us, since the weather was good at the time but maybe the cm's should be better trained.

They have to park the scooters somewhere, and moving them to the exit area makes the most sense. I don't think there's a way to get them from the loading area to the exit staying inside the attraction building. As the Op stated, there can be quite a lot of scooters there, and only a few can remain in the exit area and still keep it safe for emergencies. Also, I do not think the loading belt can handle the weight of a scooter, nor do I think it fits in the area all that well either. There would have to be a lot of backing it up, and/or multiple point turns?
 
Yes the scooters have to be parked in the exit area hallway at HM and are not under the canopy which leaves them exposed to the elements of the weather. That is why it is important to bring something along to cover your ECV for when you need to leave it. DISNEY cannot be responsible for providing a sheltered environment to protect ECVs. That is the "owner/rider's" duty. There are just too many ECVs at WDW and when it rains everyone is looking for cover.
My suggestion would be in the future is to ask the CM to clarify what they mean by a short distance when they pose that question to you at an attraction so you know specifically how far they are talking.....then you can give them a better answer. Because one CM may mean 25 ft and another may mean 100 ft. So your answer may vary each time.
But in the case of HM....you still would have probably had to park your ECV there and then use a WC back to the ride.
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom