Originally posted by wdwstar
..(snip)...i dont want to be flamed. but do you think it is fair that we cant even get a better rate first before it is offered to another group discount, i know, i know all about the 4% dvd
and im sure it all boils down to , if ms gave us great rates then we wouldnt buy more points,
but come on once in awhile throw us a bone
No flames - just want to make sure you understand why the discounts operate the way they do.
Nearly all of the rooms that are rented for cash by CRO are due to members using their points for something besides staying at a
DVC resort. Except for exchanges through II, DVC has to rent DVC resort rooms to pay for that option. Without this process, there would not be nearly so many roomns available for cash AND members wouyld not be able to use there points to do things like cruise or stay at one of the non-DVC WDW resort hotels.
Sometimes CRO needs to discount in order to make sure the rooms get rented. IMHO, this kind of discounting is one of the reasons it costs so many points for the non-DVC options. I'm hoping that in the future, we'll see a decrease in points for those options becasue CRO/WDWTC is able to rent more rooms at rack rate.
In contrast, the member discount is available whenever MS thinks all of the rooms in the MEMBER INVENTORY will not be reserved for points. I suppose they have history and statistical formulas to figure that out. It would upset me if I couldn't book a room for points and found out MS had been giving member discounts for the days I wanted. FWIW, I don't think that happens very often (if ever) and is likley the reason that member discounts are not offered all that often.
Anyway, I do think
it is fair that we cant even get a better rate first before it is offered to another group. I think it is in the memers best interests that DVC recover the cost of non-DVC options asap. Not sure how DVC members could have first crack at those rooms without a lot of extra tracking & cost.
Keep in mind that anyone, including DVC members, can rent for cash from CRO. Many members do just that if the discounts are better. I know that you might have to change rooms when you do that, but IMHO, that is the trade off for having options besides the DVC resorts.
Best wishes -