Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[CarolA]

I am surprised AI let her. I am not familiar with the law, but California has a 'young actor' law which AI has been forced to comply with. Kids must get x hours of tutroing a day. Maybe at 17 you are allowed to drop out of that program also??

And just why were the judges shocked that Aloha was voted off. THEY trashed her Monday night!

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Does anyone notice Mikayla's dramatic reaction everytime she's told that she's safe? It drives me nuts!

That's funny, b/c Dh said the same thing the last 2 weeks in a row. She drives me crazy too, but with her voice and talking more than her actions. Dh, on the other hand, is ready to throw something at the tv everytime they tell her she's safe and she acts like a drama queen. Ugh! The more I think about her the less I like her.

 

[grinningghost]

I'm thinking it will come down to Anthony and Anwar, or Bo and Anwar, and Anwar will take the prize. He seems the most versatile, with a broad knowledge of music from his experience as a music teacher.

I am really pulling for Anwar. I like Bo too, but Anwar's personality just puts him over the top for me.

Although I have a feeling Carrie's going to take it all - she just has that all-American girl thing going on and she seems to appeal to the masses. Personally, I like Amanda Avila better.

 

[damo]

Here's a tv show about Constantine (Elimidate). http://elimidate.warnerbros.com/video/quicktime3.html?v=clipweek25b

It is slow loading.

 

[sweet angel]

Here's a tv show about Constantine (Elimidate). http://elimidate.warnerbros.com/video/quicktime3.html?v=clipweek25b

It is slow loading.

That was pretty bad, but he's still cute. I think it's his smile that gets me.

 

[Philadisney]

okay, who's watching?
i don't care what simon says, i still love scott!
bo & anthony were both great too (and i DESPISE edwin mccain's music, so that's saying a lot for me!). those three all definately have my vote tonight!

 

[macraven]

you bet i am watching........

SCOTT RULES................ boy was he good.

anthony......hahaha about the chess game. so funny when ryan said," thanks for not saying ***, we appreciate that."


will be back on commercials.

 

[macraven]

and BO ROXS.............




two great singers already............still waiting for the rest.

 

[Papa Deuce]

Bo will be in the top 5.

 

[Octoberbeauty]

And the men are back tonight!!!! Not blah this week!

 

[Cindy B]

Scott was a hideous retread of a song that he has sung before. His chereography was horrible.. did I see a bit of 80's white person dance? (BTW, I am white.. so I can say that!)

 

[J.Cooper]

Anthony & Nikko did wonderful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So far I think the first 4 contestants should be in the top 12! Scott, Bo, Anthony & Nikko!

 

[Octoberbeauty]

What's with the astrological signs tonight??

 

[Cindy B]

TRAVIS--- as cute as you are.. you can go home now!

My daughter said "You look like an old man Travis!" Bobby Brown is a poor choice..

What was that rhythm thing? A poor attempt at rap?

 

[Philadisney]

macraven, i see we agree on our two favorites!

okay, i know he's hardly the best singer, but i had so much fun watching travis!!! he will be getting some votes from me as well.

this is going to be hard. so far, i don't want to see any of these guys go!

 

[J.Cooper]

Poor Travis. That was a poor song choice vocal wise. Maybe he'll get lots of sympathy votes.

Is it just me, Mario reminds me of Justin Guarini from season 1 for some reason???

 

[Shugardrawers]

GO BO BABY!!! I love him and he's not my usual type. I thought Scott did a great job. I don't expect him to win or make it terribly far in the competition but I'm so pulling for him.

 

[Cindy B]

Constantine-- You are not STING. He's off on pitch.. It just doesn't sound right... like he's not enunciating correctly. (He sounds a few octaves off, but I'm not sure)

 

[CarolA]

Constantine sounds like a cat in heat to me tonight! Who is Randy listening to???

 

[Cindy B]

Ok, what is Randy and Paula smoking? Constantine was not GOOD. If that is thier reality, I want some of it.

Go go Simon. "Bad impersonation of Sting". So true!

Ok, right now almost finished for the night.. I would say Travis and Constantine will go. I wasn't that fond of Mario either, but I just am not fond of him.

Right now Travis., possibly Constantine. Nikko did well today. I was suprised.


Anwar... lets go baby! Impress me!