We just got back from our trip on Thurs. night. We went to the party on Tuesday - it was our first time going. We dressed as Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head (and saw several others too). We thought it was
very CROWDED!!! It stormed badly last Sunday night so I was wondering if some of those people might have gotten comped a 2nd party for Tuesday & if maybe that's why it was so crowded? It stormed for about 45 minutes Tues. night (right around the time the party started). We got in line to meet Jack & Sally around 5:30 and with the weather delay it took
3 1/2 hours!!!! If had known it would take THAT long for this line to move we'd have skipped it (and I was kicking myself for not getting in line before 5:00). But once we had an hour invested in the line we hated to just give up. These were the only characters we did because it was 9:00 by the time we finished meeting them!! We also didn't really get dinner. At some point they brought a pretzel cart in by the Jack & Sally line so we got those so we wouldn't have to eat other people's children.
We got a lot of the magic shots but not ALL of them. Every time we saw a photopass photographer we got in line hoping it would be one (we didn't know how to tell if they were or not). We missed the 1st parade because of Jack & Sally but caught the 2nd parade, one of the castle shows, the fireworks & the very last Hocus Pocus show. We somehow managed to slip back to Fantasyland for passholder pins in-between things (it was late) and found a magic shot back there too. The line for pins wasn't that long when we went (but it was during the last hour of the night). The only ride we did was HM. We got the magic shot there but Madame Carlotta was not out when we were there.

Also, there was no Headless Horseman in our parade. I thought that was a given that he would be there? Is that not always the case? That was a bummer. We slowly worked our way out of the park after the last Hocus Pocus (stopped for ice cream on the corner) and for some more nighttime photopass shots (because it was daylight when we got there at 4:00). We were literally still in line at 1:00 AM for the one up front in the circle with the pumpkin towers and the magic shot ghosts. LOVED that they were in it (we didn't know if there would be anything show up or not). Main Street was EMPTY by this time and they said the buses were about to stop running!! We only went thru a couple of treat lines - we weren't really there for the candy & it was just the 2 of us. Hope we can go again one day - lessons learned the hard way on character lines. Next time I read somewhere on the DIS or Kenny the Pirate or ITM that we should be in line by X___ time we will do it or else we'll skip it!!!!