Offical American Idol Discussion Thread

[hucifer]

Originally posted by TiggerPiglet
Yes, there was an episode of AI last night and it was not in the TV Guide. There is also a show on tonight, which I don't think is listed in the TV Guide either. I guess they decided last minute to put more shows on.

Thanks for the news, TiggerPiglet! That irritates me that I missed it.

 

[musicalSaranader]

I didn't see much of Miss ex-DCL-performer tonight, but I like her, so I'll hope and assume she got through. And I somehow found myself PRAYING for Johnny to get through tonight! He's my favorite; I love him. He has such a smooth, unique voice, style, and personality, and he's so adorable! So you can all probably guess my excitement after tonight's show

Sorry if I spoiled it for anyone....

 

[Tess]

Miss DCL was in the group that made it through. There was a very brief shot of her "group" practicing for the next round in a hallway.

I was so glad to see the foul-mouthed blonde teen get the boot. She was swearing at her father in the elevator on her way out the door--don't let it hit you on the way out my dear! If I recall correctly, she is the one that Paula said was "affected" and the kid didn't even know what that meant--FAKE honey! She was all of that and a bag of chips!

 

[gometros]

I agree with the teen that got the boot. She was such a put on.

Sara - which one is Johnny?

WHy is it that every AI there is someone who is a real screw up, but because he/she is hot looking they let it go? Last time it was Corey and this time it's Alan. Did his swimming partner go through? Did anyone notice if the vertically challenged girl went through?

 

[ead79]

gometros, I get so mad that they always let the "good looking" screw ups through too. It just ticks me off! No wonder these people don't think the rules apply to them--everything is handed to them on a platter because they are "fine."

I didn't notice if the young lady with dwarfism got through or not. I never saw a single clip of her in Hollywood.

 

[love the magic]

Originally posted by gometros
Did anyone notice if the vertically challenged girl went through?

I DID see her in one of the rooms that have gone through to the next round! Tonight should be GREAT!

Have a great day!

 

[Jeafl]

Yes, the small woman made it through. I saw a shot of her hugging Paula at the end.

The one that REALLY ticks me off is the one who was so nasty to Simon, calling him gay and really letting him have it. I loved Paula's reprimand to her though. I still can't believe that she made it through. Then at the end, they showed her hugging Simon. What is up with that??

 

[cheeringmom]

Originally posted by Jeafl
Yes, the small woman made it through. I saw a shot of her hugging Paula at the end.

The one that REALLY ticks me off is the one who was so nasty to Simon, calling him gay and really letting him have it. I loved Paula's reprimand to her though. I still can't believe that she made it through. Then at the end, they showed her hugging Simon. What is up with that??

But did you see Paula's face who was standing next to Simon? Not at all thrilled with the rude woman. She did have a nice song and voice however. Too bad she went too far with her comments

 

[damo]

The yodeller girl with the attitude needs a new voice coach, I think that is where a lot of her bad singing is coming from. I like Alan, he'll be on a sitcom before long I bet. I was glad to see that the Kira girl with the attitude (the gay comments) got through. She's got a lot of anger that she needs to work through and maybe she learned a lesson! Can't wait for tonight.

 

[scarlett873]

i think kira (the attitude gal who called simon gay) was a it remorseful about what she had said/did later on. i'm glad that she got through...i just hope that she shapes up!

i can't believe that alan and that model girl (i think that was her anyway) got through! alan needs to quit touching himself when he sings...lol

i was sooooooooo happy to see little miss foul mouth teen get the boot! i HATED her voice...

i really like the red-head guy with the frank sinatra sounding voice. i just don't know how well he'll do singing other genres of music...

can't wait for tonight!! it's on at 8:30!!!

 

[CookieGVB]

I'd bet Simon convinced the other two to let Ms. Attitude on through. It'll make for great ratings.

Both of the "swimmers" made it through. That just aggravated me to no end...

 

[Kirby]

I hated to see that Alan made it through. He has a good voice but I just don't care for him. Did the girl he was swimming with make it last night?

My son asked me this morning when we could start voting and if I was. I told him that it would be soon and yes, I was going to vote but only for someone that I thought I would enjoy listening to. There are a couple, as always, that if they make it through to the voting process, will be bumped up just because of their looks, personality, etc. not for their singing ability. It happens every time.

One guy I really like is from New York (I think). He wore a white cap on his head. He reminds me of one of the guys who made it to the final 10 last year but has a much better voice.

 

[airhead]

Man,she's whacked!!

 

[nancy679]

Just a reminder, tonites show is on at 8:30-9:30, (not 8p)

 

[Kirby]

Just a reminder, tonites show is on at 8:30-9:30, (not 8p)

7:30 CST

 

[cinmell]

Originally posted by scarlett873

i was sooooooooo happy to see little miss foul mouth teen get the boot! i HATED her voice...

Me too!!! Seems to me like she's been surrounded by too much positive reinforcement about her singing over the years .

I hope pool boy and girl, scooter girl and disrespect girl will get the boot tonight. In a sort of way I'm hoping that the judges are messing with them by letting them stay a bit longer then giving them the ax tonight!

 

[DemonLlama]

Yes, swimming-with-Alan chick got through -- she was the one that disappeared when her two partners were trying to find her in order to practice their group stuff.

I'm glad the little woman made it through -- I was looking for her and never saw a sign of her.

I'll have to tape the first half 'cause there's a new Smallville on tonight, and DH's logic is that HIS show is only on ONCE a week!

 

[Sandy V.]

Was anybody else really offended by the foul-mouthed "affected" 16 year old's treatment of her father in the elevator? After seeing the mother in action, it's easy to tell the acorn doesn't fall far from the tree!

I've got a 16 year old daughter myself and I recognize the "attitude" that comes with it sometimes, but if she ever attempted to pull that prima donna disrespectful CRAP with either me or her father, there would be heck to pay!

Glad she's gone. I don't think she realizes it, but I think she'll get crucified for her horrible behavior for quite awhile!

 

[cheeringmom]

Originally posted by Sandy V.
Was anybody else really offended by the foul-mouthed "affected" 16 year old's treatment of her father in the elevator? After seeing the mother in action, it's easy to tell the acorn doesn't fall far from the tree!

I've got a 16 year old daughter myself and I recognize the "attitude" that comes with it sometimes, but if she ever attempted to pull that prima donna disrespectful CRAP with either me or her father, there would be heck to pay!

Glad she's gone. I don't think she realizes it, but I think she'll get crucified for her horrible behavior for quite awhile!

Hear hear!!!

 

[CruiserDew73]

I'm really mad that nicole got booted! She was definately my favorite and i thought she could win it!