Honestly, I'd take a second look and then look at the life away from the church. That's what I would do.
I think we're treading on dangerous ground when someone's choice of church is a factor in our political life. We should have a reasonable expectation of privacy in that service. We should have a reasonable expectation that the church isn't being infiltrated by someone looking to score a political point. We should have a reasonable expectation that a relationship with one's pastor is a private one. And we sure as hell shouldn't be required to answer for every damned thing about one's religious life.
Examine it? Sure, but it wouldn't be my only criteria or even a major criteria. I get the feeling for too many here, the decision was already made and this entire discussion is nothing more than showboating, posturing, and pontification.