Hi All,
Since I see the latest topic has been excursions, I'd love some advice if anyone has any re: our situation.
We've been to St. Maarten before with Disney, but we did a
Disney cruise excursion (a beach break, which was a ton of fun, especially for the kids). But, this time, we want to go to Maho beach (I think that is the name), which is the beach right next to the airport runway, so jets literally fly right over your head. It's pretty amazing from what I've heard.
Our oldest son (who will be 11 at the time of the cruise) LOVES planes, flying, airports... pretty much anything related to the topic, and so it is his dream to go see these planes land and take off, and the rest of our family really wants to go, too!! Sounds so much fun to me!
I have looked into options to getting to this beach, since this is not an excursion with Disney, and I can't decide which is best and the smartest option, so was wondering if any experienced cruisers who have been to St. Maarten more than once can offer any friendly advice.
These are the two options I know of:
Option 1) rent a car and we drive on our own (this will allow us to go wherever we want, including the airport beach, and stay as long as we want wherever we go. However, the big jets (747's, etc) don't land until 2 or 3 PM, so we want to hit Maho beach in the afternoon. But, from what I've heard and read Maho Beach is across the island from the port, and I understand that traffic on St. Maarten can be terrible in the afternoon at rush hour. So, my one and only concern about renting a car is that we won't time it right to get back to the ship, and we will get stuck in traffic and miss the ship, and that would be devastating!!! So, I think I'd be stressed out come the afternoon about getting back to the ship. But, maybe I'm making a bigger deal out of it, and if we have to be back to the ship by 6 PM, and we leave the beach by 4 PM, we should have enough time?? I have no idea!
Option 2) I have heard about an independant tour company called Bernard's Tours. I have heard they are super good and know how to make sure you are back to the ship in time. They take people to the airport beach, and they know the plane schedule, so they make sure you are there when the heavy's (747's) land and from what I heard, they stay about 45 minutes at the beach in the afternoon, and then they take you to a few other places in the morning. That is the group tour which I've heard is reasonably priced. But, then you can do a private tour which is more expensive (more expensive than a rental car for sure), but this way we could customize the amount of time we spend at each place we go to, including Maho Beach at the airport, as well as customize where we go rather than their standard route, BUT the plus side is the driver would know what time we need to start heading back to the ship in order to get there in time becuase they know the ins and outs of traffic, and what best routes to take, etc. From what I've heard and read, they always get you back to the ship in time.
So, I'm trying to weigh out the pros and cons here, and was hoping to get some input from any of you.
1) The rental car option:
Pros - we can go wherever we want, whenever we want... just be on our own. It is cheaper than Bernards Tours for the 4 of us.
Cons - we (or I) will probably be more stressed out afraid we won't get back to the ship in time, or get lost on the island, or stuck in traffic because we don't know the traffic patterns.
2) Bernards tour option:
Pros - not stressful because they willl know timing of everything, they navigate around island, we are just passengers, will not stress about getting back to ship on time.
Cons - much more expensive than a rental car if we do a private tour with just our family. Less expensive (but probably still more expensive than a rental car) if we do a group tour (cheaper option with Bernards tours), but then we are stuck to their general tour route (so might end up going places we aren't as intrested in), and if we decide we LOVE Maho Beach and want to stay there longer than 45 minutes, then we are out of luck because from what I've read, this is how long the general group tour stays at this beach(and this particular beach is literally the ONE and ONLY thing my son is looking forward to on St. Maarten, and we are calling it his 11th b-day present, since he turns 11 on Nov 3, so I'd feel bad if because of the group tour timing we had to leave if we are having a super good time and want to stay longer than 45 minutes).
So, I can't decide which is best... my husband thinks renting a car is just fine, but he never worries about anything! haha. So, I know I'd be the one stressing about getting back to ship on our own. So, he is letting me decide if we do Bernards Tours or the rental car.
Or, maybe someone here knows of another option for us that is even better than the two I have mentioned here! If so, I'd love to hear.

(Oh, btw, in case someone wants to recommend a taxi, I have heard that a taxi would not even be an option because it'd cost too much, plus, at Maho Beach, I've heard and read that it's hard to catch a taxi from the beach, so I don't think a taxi is an option for us.... but please correct me if I'm wrong! I'm only going by what I've read online).
Thanks!
Kathy
ps. sorry for such a long post, but this is literally the one and only thing I am unsure about on our whole cruise!