No more smoking or vaping in the parks

Status
Not open for further replies.
At the risk of being attacked, and perhaps thrown off the board, I’ll give my thoughts. First, second hand smoke, outdoors is harmless. It’s unbelievable how many people worry about passing a smoker outdoors, but at 50 pounds overweight (or more) think nothing of walking down Main Street with burger in one hand and s Mickey Barr in the other.
I a aware that many people don’t like to pass the smoking areas. The easy answer is, as smokers had to walk out of our way to the smoking area to smoke, why not go a few steps out of their way to avoid passing it? Oh, right, many are too out of shape to take 5 extra steps...but they’re worried about my second hand smoke. Really??!
You might not be as physically fit when you inevitably develop COPD or worse. Bottom line is smoking is a public nuisance and the majority of ppl don’t smoke & shouldn’t have to go out of their way to avoid it. Most public spaces have banned it completely & for good reason.
 
Why all this talk about the economic classification and generalizations about people who smoke?
It's almost as if people are responding with these economic "facts" as a reason why there won't be any impact on Disney's bottom line.
Perhaps it somehow justifies the condemnation of smokers. It's as if it is being suggested that lower socio-economic groups need to be "guided" in their personal substance choices.
Disney treated these people with no regard. Giving 30 days notice is a joke.


Agreed Col! I think people are losing sight of PEOPLE (maybe think beyond themselves for a split second) and just googling stuff to “win” a debate. The original “poor people” post inferred negativity and “put downs”.

The original post inferred that Disney isn’t marketing to the Average Joe and marketing to the upper echelon. And that the upper echelon doesn’t smoke because it is “low brow” and “no smoking” will keep the blue collar folks at home and lure the white collar. (I noted that I personally know more white collar smokers vs blue collar...including my father specifically). Sorry but they are marketing to the AVERAGE American family not the rich. Disney World vacations are as much of the American Dream as the white picket fence.

If they are trying to lure in only the rich, white collar they hired the wrong marketing firm. Even the Grand Floridian doesn’t meet “luxury” standards and the smoking sections there always have occupants. My father actually refers to the Grand as Disney’s very own Red Roof Inn when we stay there lol. But then again, apparently because my father smokes he’s poor, low brow, stupid, uneducated, selfish, inconsiderate, among other insults being slung his way. But, like myself, he doesn’t like or approve of alcohol consumption especially in public and even more so if you’re drinking while taking care of your kids. Even though he doesn’t like or approve of it he doesn’t sling insults, offer unsolicited advice, or pass judgement at those who do. Instead he pulls up a chair, gets to know you, jokes and laughs, make napkin animals for your kids and tells you he’s a gas pump attendant because he’s sensitive people will treat him differently or be intimidated by his actual career. He’ll even pay for your cab ride home or a hotel for the night to make sure you and others are safe. But again...so many want to categorize him and make him out to be the Boogie Man because he enjoys sauntering over to a DSA, relaxing a bit and enjoy a smoke on his vacation. By the way, he’s met some of the most fascinating and nicest people in those DSA’s.

If Disney decided to go dry (which obviously they won’t but...), the outcry would be greater as would the empathy, compassion or heck, even just being supportive and kind.
 
I wonder if DCL will ban it altogether at some point as well. That would be great!

I don't understand the concern that foreign visitors will now abandon the parks because other parts of the world are more used to being able to still smoke around the general population. If those foreign visitors are at DW, doesn't that mean they had to tolerate a many-hour plane flight without their "fix" ? Therefore, they shouldn't have an issue. Further, if US park visitors are so upset that now they will just go to Disney Paris, since smoking is more okay there for now, don't they also need a 7-8 hour plane flight (where they will not be able to get their fix)? How will they manage that if they can't manage a few hours in the Orlando parks?

They sleep and snack and as soon as the plane lands, they bolt out the door, then go back in for their luggage.

I know a lot of former addicts (members of a recovery program at my old church), and it is not at all uncommon for an addict to have a job. They would of course have to have a job that doesn’t do drug testing.

It wasn’t even unheard of to have a high paying job.
I dont know any drug addicts, but I work with an alcoholic. She is BOMBED every night. Ive been on a few business trips with her and she never attends the team building activites or dinners, but goes to the hotel bar and gets started on the drinking. By midnight, she cant even form a full sentence, but at 7am, shes up and on her A game. Have no idea how she does it. Id be in bed for days. Cant call her for any emergency at night/weekends. This has been going on for at least 10 years. Everyone is aware, but it doesnt affect her work.
 

Realize Disney has crunched the numbers before coming out with these BANS. The attendance is up every year and they know this will not have a negative impact on their gate. If they thought it would, they would NEVER implement these BANS. Sure, you will initially get people to say I am not going if I can't smoke, but the reality that will die down and those people will go back. And for the few that don't go back, they are a blip on the screen to Disney. Unfortunately, for all of us Disney fanatics, we all have a few things we don't like about it, but yet, still go back. And Disney knows this. As much as Disney tries to make each of us feel special and our needs are met, the true reality, we are just a number. And if we stop going, there is always someone else stepping up in our place.

As for the smoking ban, i agree with Disney. Too many rule breakers and why should certain parts of the park, have that constant smoke lingering, even if they are less popular areas. There are alternatives for the few hours you are in the park...such as nicotine based products. With the way the rest of public places treat smoking in the US, Disney is behind the 8 ball on this... The same way people have adjusted to hanging out in a restaurant or bar without smoking, they will figure out a way to go to Disney and smoke less or smoke free. Remember the general uproar of smokers when bars and restaurants started banning smoking. How many people said i cant drink a beer without having a cigarette. Yet, somehow when i go out, local bars and restaurants are thriving... People adjust.

Someone posted earlier, that Disney has all these rules, which no ones enforces, which lead to these BANS. I agree with that. There are many people that feel the rules don't apply to them or they are there to try to get over on the Disney system because they have paid a lot for their vacation and don't want to be told no. In the end, rule breakers lead to these BANS. Disney could take a stronger stance on lots of things which would overall make it better for everyone and lead to less BANS.
 
I just realized that the reason for only giving 30 days notice about the smoking ban, is tied into profits.
Summer is filled with people who already made their plans, and August will be filled with Star Wars fans. So no economic changes will be noticed by the smoking ban.
Smart Disney...very smart.
I disagree it has anything to to with the season.
  • Star Wars is opening at DLR less than a month after the bans to into effect.
  • Coordination of all restrictions at all U.S. parks at once.
  • The one DSA in DL is on the path to SW:GE.
  • Summer is probably less busy overall than other periods (value vs regular vs peak vs holiday) seasons.
  • Numerous unrelated restrictions all go into effect at the same time.
Agreed Col! I think people are losing sight of PEOPLE (maybe think beyond themselves for a split second) and just googling stuff to “win” a debate. The original “poor people” post inferred negativity and “put downs”.
Thing is, while the (CDC) data includes percentages, they don't provide many numbers.
21% of persons with incomes under 35K smoke, while only 8% of those earning over 100K do.
But if there are 10,000 people in the lowest income pool, and 30,000 in the highest (actual numbers made up because it's not in the stats, but percents are accurate), that's 2,100 smokers in the lowest bracket and 2,400 smokers in the highest.
 
[QUOTE="kaytieeldr, post: 60446159, member: 89931"
  • Summer is probably less busy overall than other periods (value vs regular vs peak vs holiday) seasons.[/QUOTE]

The WORST times to visit Walt Disney World are:
December 26-31
Mid-February through mid-April
Midsummer (June through early August).

If kids are out of school (summer), the parks are crowded.
 
[QUOTE="kaytieeldr, post: 60446159, member: 89931"
  • Summer is probably less busy overall than other periods (value vs regular vs peak vs holiday) seasons.
The WORST times to visit Walt Disney World are:
December 26-31
Mid-February through mid-April
Midsummer (June through early August).

If kids are out of school (summer), the parks are crowded.[/QUOTE]


Typically, yes, summer is busy. From reports this year is less so, due to people holding back for Star Wars Land.
 
Typically, yes, summer is busy. From reports this year is less so, due to people holding back for Star Wars Land.

I just looked in my TA system. WDW has ZERO promos right now for after 05/28. Ive never seen that. Maybe a new one will pop up tomorrow, but as of today, they are not offering any discounts for anyone who has not already booked their summer vacation. CRAZY
 
For me I am kinda happy about the no smoking thing! Now my husband will need to stop smoking/vaping since he can't do it on our vacation =)
As far as the no ice to me I look at it like this.......Maybe it is a security thing, or maybe they don't want water dripping all over the place. Maybe it is a safety thing. So I can buy some blue icepacks before I leave and freeze them in the freezer each night. No big deal!
For the strollers I TOTALLY understand! Safety first! Plus pushing a large stroller through the stores, or crowds is hard enough!
 
For me I am kinda happy about the no smoking thing! Now my husband will need to stop smoking/vaping since he can't do it on our vacation =)
As far as the no ice to me I look at it like this.......Maybe it is a security thing, or maybe they don't want water dripping all over the place. Maybe it is a safety thing. So I can buy some blue icepacks before I leave and freeze them in the freezer each night. No big deal!
For the strollers I TOTALLY understand! Safety first! Plus pushing a large stroller through the stores, or crowds is hard enough!
:confused: What freezer? I don't know of many hotel rooms that have freezers, certainly none of the on-sites except the full-kitchen villas. As to the safety hazard of ice, well, I've not heard of there being so many incidents or near-misses that it was a problem demanding to be solved. The strollers are a big PIA but it's been 20 years since my kid needed one so maybe I'm less than objective. :rolleyes1
 
Typically, yes, summer is busy. From reports this year is less so, due to people holding back for Star Wars Land.
Actually summer hasn't been as busy for something like 2 years now. Fall has actually been very busy. The crowds shifted. Summer discounts were given when they typically weren't before. Fall discounts were more restricted like October being excluded I believe from Free Dining (I believe). Star Wars had nothing to do with crowds last year during summer being much more manageable than people ever thought.
 
What's your opinion on treating nicotine addition as a medical condition? :rolleyes1 Doesn't seem to be too much sympathy for that...
I think that lack of sympathy will change when the thousands and thousands of tweens and teens hooked on juuls with their ridiculously high nicotine levels try to quit. Mammas are not going to tell their 15 year old to suck it up and quit cold turkey all on their own. They will be reaching out to medical professionals for help.
 
It DEFINTELY sounds like a PIA, and with small kids I would also not want to deal with it (but I am not a smoker). I do think it is a matter of getting used to the rule. Also, there are plenty of families that handle parks like the San Diego Zoo, which is smoke free. I read that you cannot even smoke in the parking lot. Over 4 million visited the zoo in 2018 (and 1.5 million visited the Safari, also smoke free). While this is only a small fraction of visitors who visit the Disney parks, it can be managed.
It will have to come down to touring priorities for smokers. I feel badly for the families if the priority if going out to smoke. Someone in the news section posted that it would have been better if Disney did not allow smoking anywhere on property, including the resorts. I can't help but think that would have been kinder. Maybe if they get tired of poking enough bears it will come down to that.

We changed our touring style due to the overwhelming crowds at MK, we chose not to go to that park... it was shoulder to shoulder last Nov. It will save us the aggravation and bruised legs from strollers and scooters. We both have been going to the MK since '72 so I'm a bit saddened. There are still other parks we enjoy so we will carry on!

Perhaps the teeth ads are showing up because of the smoking thread? Tooth loss is common in smokers. :duck:

Have a wonderful Sunday! If you are in the parks, enjoy the beautiful weather today.
 
It is a generalization based on data, not a personal judgment or condemnation. The smoking rate for Americans with a GED is NINE TIMES the rate for Americans with a graduate degree. Income-wise, the rate for people earning less than $35K/year is twice what it is for people making $70K or more. There are, of course, exceptions - someone makes up that single-digit percentage of educated, higher-earning Americans who smoke - but smokers as a whole are a lower-income, less educated group than the population as a whole.
True. Data is unbiased information gathered from a large sample of people. It may or may not match the individuals we each personally know.

That smoking is a low-income choice is a fact. We all know individuals who don't "fit the mold", but that doesn't mean the data was wrong. So, again, true.
I also thought about the demographics of smokers & when I first heard thought maybe it was an attempt by wdw to control who is in the parks. If it’s not a direct attempt to do that, I don’t think they are concerned at all about whether this demographic is upset about the change.
I think you're overthinking this. Most non-smokers don't like smoking, and they'd rather not spend $$$$ for a day where they have to walk through smoke. They complain.
I dont know any drug addicts, but I work with an alcoholic. She is BOMBED every night. Ive been on a few business trips with her and she never attends the team building activites or dinners, but goes to the hotel bar and gets started on the drinking. By midnight, she cant even form a full sentence, but at 7am, shes up and on her A game. Have no idea how she does it. Id be in bed for days. Cant call her for any emergency at night/weekends. This has been going on for at least 10 years. Everyone is aware, but it doesnt affect her work.
Lucky you. I do know drug addicts.

Your boss is a Functional Alcoholic. My father was one too; he successfully held a professional job. Until -- suddenly and finally -- he couldn't do it any more. All Functional Alcoholics (if they don't kill themselves with drink first) will hit a wall.
I think that lack of sympathy will change when the thousands and thousands of tweens and teens hooked on juuls with their ridiculously high nicotine levels try to quit. Mammas are not going to tell their 15 year old to suck it up and quit cold turkey all on their own. They will be reaching out to medical professionals for help.
These Juuls things are bad news, yet our teens think they're no big deal. They like bringing them to school because they can "use" in a bathroom stall without producing smoke or smell, making it easier to get away with them. Some of them look like ink pens, so they're super easy to hide.

I was sadly ignorant of this phenomenon until we had a training on them at school. We saw a video of a kid in our own school pass out after "using" in the bathroom. Our school nurse says they scare her to death: she says they'll have a heart beat of 200+ per minute, yet the kid reports, "I feel fine -- better than fine!" Every high school in my county has sent multiple kids to the hospital in an ambulance after "using". They are more dangerous than cigarettes.
Perhaps the teeth ads are showing up because of the smoking thread? Tooth loss is common in smokers.
Eh, maybe. But both of my children (both rabidly anti-smoking) have tooth implants; both were born missing teeth, and they both received implants as high school seniors. I think being born missing teeth is uncommon, but certainly not rare. My aunt (a non-smoker) has lost several teeth to age, and she's in the process of having a couple dental implants. Yeah, smokers may be a part of this group, but they're not the whole story.
 
For some even "real motivation" is not enough. The addiction is just too strong. I have quit and did well for 2 years and started back. I know I can quit again. Chantix is a wonderful thing. But you can't say that "everyone" will quit with the right motivation otherwise you wouldn't see so many people smoking and dragging around an oxygen tank.



Nicotine isn't even in all the drops for vapes. They control how much nicotine is in them. And some are now using the vapes for anxiety and depression with CBD in them.
Totally agree! I tried Chantix when it first came out. It didn’t agree with me. All of those things listed that can be side effects, I had about a 1/3 of them. I really wish it would have worked for me. I am however very happy it works for most people. I also tried vaping which didn’t work either.
So, I’m still addicted and not happy at all about the ban. I have an AP and 2 trips planned and I can’t disappoint the people I am taking. So, I’ll make these 2 trips and walk the mile back and forth several times a day. After those trips and my AP expiring, I just may be phased out of Disney. I’ll even have to get a new license plate for my car I suppose :sad2: since it reads “DISNYFAN”.
 
Agreed Col! I think people are losing sight of PEOPLE (maybe think beyond themselves for a split second) and just googling stuff to “win” a debate. The original “poor people” post inferred negativity and “put downs”.

The original post inferred that Disney isn’t marketing to the Average Joe and marketing to the upper echelon. And that the upper echelon doesn’t smoke because it is “low brow” and “no smoking” will keep the blue collar folks at home and lure the white collar. (I noted that I personally know more white collar smokers vs blue collar...including my father specifically). Sorry but they are marketing to the AVERAGE American family not the rich. Disney World vacations are as much of the American Dream as the white picket fence.

If they are trying to lure in only the rich, white collar they hired the wrong marketing firm. Even the Grand Floridian doesn’t meet “luxury” standards and the smoking sections there always have occupants. My father actually refers to the Grand as Disney’s very own Red Roof Inn when we stay there lol. But then again, apparently because my father smokes he’s poor, low brow, stupid, uneducated, selfish, inconsiderate, among other insults being slung his way. But, like myself, he doesn’t like or approve of alcohol consumption especially in public and even more so if you’re drinking while taking care of your kids. Even though he doesn’t like or approve of it he doesn’t sling insults, offer unsolicited advice, or pass judgement at those who do. Instead he pulls up a chair, gets to know you, jokes and laughs, make napkin animals for your kids and tells you he’s a gas pump attendant because he’s sensitive people will treat him differently or be intimidated by his actual career. He’ll even pay for your cab ride home or a hotel for the night to make sure you and others are safe. But again...so many want to categorize him and make him out to be the Boogie Man because he enjoys sauntering over to a DSA, relaxing a bit and enjoy a smoke on his vacation. By the way, he’s met some of the most fascinating and nicest people in those DSA’s.

If Disney decided to go dry (which obviously they won’t but...), the outcry would be greater as would the empathy, compassion or heck, even just being supportive and kind.
This has nothing to do with socioeconomic reasons. That is ridiculous to even try to use as an excuse to why Disney does not like smokers. Whining that Disney doesn't like me or doesn't want me is crazy. They want you, they don't want the smoke.

Any decision a for-profit business makes is purely financial and based on what will boost the bottom line. The vast majority of the world does not smoke. Models across the country have shown that going smoke-free is good for the bottom line. Yes, there are still a few spots in the country, Vegas comes to mind, where going smoke-free would impact the bottom line but those are diminishing quickly. There is a very strong global anti-smoking movement. Non-smokers prefer smoke-free environments. They are more apt to go somewhere that is smoke free than not. Models have shown that in entertainment venues, particularly ones that cater to families, for every smoker that boycotts, there are several non-smokers that will fill their spot.

This is not unique to Disney, going smoke-free is becoming more and more common throughout the country and growing stronger in the world.

You can't go to an NFL game and smoke (most of the stadiums do NOT have DSAs within the stadium, you have to leave to smoke,) you can't go to a concert, a ball game, a movie, a restaurant, a bar, most entertainment venues and still be allowed to smoke. Only 3 states in the US do not have some sort of public smoking ban. More and more cities are banning smoking in their city limits completely so that means no smoking outside after your meal even on their property (no decks, no smoking patios, etc allowed.)

Even I was shocked yesterday when I found out a brand new bowling alley, a bowling alley, the bastion of smoking, was just built within our city limits which bans smoking completely except in cars. A bowling alley, something that has the stereotype (false but it is there) of being blue collar entertainment. And it is thriving being smoke free. People are flocking to it because they can bowl without smoke.

It is purely a business decision, one that many, many, many businesses across the country are making. It has nothing to do with health, with socio-economic status, that the business doesn't "like" a certain group of people. It only has to do with satisfying the share holders and the only way to do that is to increase the bottom line.
 
Even I was shocked yesterday when I found out a brand new bowling alley, a bowling alley, the bastion of smoking, was just built within our city limits which bans smoking completely except in cars. A bowling alley, something that has the stereotype (false but it is there) of being blue collar entertainment. And it is thriving being smoke free. People are flocking to it because they can bowl without smoke.
I'm pretty sure the bowling alleys here are smoke free though I haven't checked each and every one.

I know you used to be able to smoke in them but I believe the ones that are smoke free (which may very well be all of them) it's the city who has included them on the "public enclosed spaces" part of smoking being prohibited and since I can't remember of a city here that you can smoke inside (other than casinos that comes to mind) they might all be smoke free for a while now.
 
For me I am kinda happy about the no smoking thing! Now my husband will need to stop smoking/vaping since he can't do it on our vacation =)
As far as the no ice to me I look at it like this.......Maybe it is a security thing, or maybe they don't want water dripping all over the place. Maybe it is a safety thing. So I can buy some blue icepacks before I leave and freeze them in the freezer each night. No big deal!
For the strollers I TOTALLY understand! Safety first! Plus pushing a large stroller through the stores, or crowds is hard enough!

:confused: What freezer? I don't know of many hotel rooms that have freezers, certainly none of the on-sites except the full-kitchen villas. As to the safety hazard of ice, well, I've not heard of there being so many incidents or near-misses that it was a problem demanding to be solved. The strollers are a big PIA but it's been 20 years since my kid needed one so maybe I'm less than objective. :rolleyes1

I admit the ice thing puzzles me too. The "freezers" in those tiny fridges are pretty sad, so I doubt bringing the gel packs would work very well. - Maybe Disney just hopes people give up bringing coolers in because they'll buy more park food and the security lines will move faster?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top