DS & I did the ride at Honeysuckle in June. We arrived in plenty of time -- picked up the tender ticket @ 8:30, arrived a few minutes later, & were picked up around 9:30. The actual horseback ride is about an hour & a half. The whole trip lasted till almost noon (there is a drive to get to the beach where they keep their horses). The stretch of beach was GORGEOUS!!! We were then taken back to the meeting place, with a quick stop for water at a local store - that was very nice of the wife/owner.
DS 11 had never ridden before & I was really happy with how they handled everything for him -- he loved it!
Now the precautions...
As for me, I was a bit put off by the husband/owner (sorry - don't know names) when we went. I explained that I hadn't ridden in many many years & was very nervous about the whole thing, but he still put me on a very "demanding" horse & then later snapped & chastised me for not letting him know I wasn't a skilled, confident rider. That was a bit much since the whole time he was assignning horses I kept asking for a more tame & gentle one. I finally said, "but I did tell you!!" & he just sort of grumbled & rode off & left me there feeling very insecure. Not so good, but the horse was fine & didn't "take off" or "lay down" like he had threatened he might...
BUT, because DS had so much fun, & it was such a beautiful beach, & the horse did behave, I tried to take the whole thing in stride -- didn't really like getting scared & yelled at, though. I still had a good time & would highly recommend the wife/owner as a wonderful guide & listener!! If you go, just make sure you are VERY clear with the husband about what you need -- I guess I wasn't loud enough??
Also make sure you bring some water!! It was very hot & we forgot ours. They didn't have any place for you to get a drink there! And don't wear a hat unless you are prepared to lose it. I bought DS a Grand Cayman hat while we were waiting to be picked up, it fell off when his horse began to trot, I asked the husband/owner if he would grab it, & he yelled, "the hat stays!" & refused to pick it up even though he was separate from the group & sitting on his horse right beside where it fell. That was a bit weird, but I had already learned that he was to be avoided...
Sorry for all the disclaimers... we really did have a good time!