WE thought it was a good deal for us. We were considering an add-on through resale. That's how we bought our other points because we felt that was the best deal at the time. Our first contract was purchased 3 years ago and second contract 2 years ago. However, this time we felt the resale prices were so high that it was a better deal directly from Disney. In addition to the free APs we were also given the 2005 points. It worked for us!