a4matte
Mouseketeer
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2014
- Messages
- 263
I agree- there is no denying the link between Ghastlies and the 2017 Halloween merch. Heads will roll.
If they dealt with this before, with Alice items, wouldn't they take steps to make sure it didn't happen again? I feel like even a Google image search would have picked up on the Ghastlies and avoided all this. If I paid for a party ticket, I would be ticked at the lack of party merchandise.
Ehhhh... it can be hard to find a similar style just through google. There are tons of different artworks and styles out there. And I've definitely never seen the Ghastlies until someone else mentioned it on Facebook.
I can tell you how this may have happened since I deal with this fairly often. Professionally I am a designer and many of the things I work on have a lot of exposure throughout the globe so I have to be cautious when things like this happen. It's possible the project manager sent over some images of the Ghastlies to the illustrator and said "I want it done in this style." Some of the project managers I've been dealing with with my clients lately seem to not understand that you can't just rip off someone else's artwork. I get TONS of reference from places like Etsy, Pinterest, and Google. These conversations tend to work like this: "I found this photo on Google and I love it, I want to use it on _____" 'Sorry, we can't do that. That photo is copyright to someone else. Just because you found it on Google doesn't mean you can use it.' Of course we've used some of those references as inspiration for our work, but we are careful to make it different enough to simply be "inspired by" whatever it is they sent.
It's also possible that the illustrator is the one who made the decision to use the style. That person may not have brought it to the attention of the project managers that they used it for style reference. I feel like if they had, a good project manager would have asked for more changes after seeing the two next to each other. They're simply WAY too close and legal would have lost their minds over it LONG before it went into production.