New Twilight Thread: Forks or La Push? Hmmmmmm....

[OneTreeHill]

The book sucked. In my opinion but
more then 75% of twilighters agree with me.

I don't think it sucked.
I think it could have been better, and I was expecting more.
But, it wasn't terrible.

 

[valeriesunshine]

Entertainment Weekly gave it a D

 

[OneTreeHill]

Entertainment Weekly gave it a D

Ouch.
That sucks.


I agree that it couldn have been better.
But, I actually liked it.
Not as much as the other books, but that's okay.

 

[CrazySteph]

Yeah, he does.

Emmett literally made me laugh out loud.

Warning: I will talk about this book a lot since its Aug 9th!!

I agree!! Emmett was soo FUNNY!! like when he was making all those sex jokes about Bella to her father!! !lol aw man aw man !!

and Jacob made me laugh too!!! espeically when he threw the dish at Rosalie's head.

and Jacob made me laugh everytime Edward would like respond to one of his thoughts.

 

[AmandaSparks730]

is that the one writen in his sig?

Yep!

 

[AbsoluteAwesome1]

I didn't hate it.
I hated the beginning because Bella was too sex-crazed and I didn't like the bit where Jacob narrated.

I really liked the rest, though.
Nessie is one of my favorite characters. XD
Team Sea Monster FTW.

 

[CastawayJ]

I love jacob soooo much... but I'm not sure now cuz ed is mad and I don't know why... yet

they just got back from hunting for the first time

 

[AmandaSparks730]

I love jacob soooo much... but I'm not sure now cuz ed is mad and I don't know why... yet

they just got back from hunting for the first time

Good boy; you like Jake now.

Let's attack Billy!

 

[3mtn-kate]

I didn't hate it.
I hated the beginning because Bella was too sex-crazed and I didn't like the bit where Jacob narrated.
I really liked the rest, though.
Nessie is one of my favorite characters. XD
Team Sea Monster FTW.

really???

I thought that was kinda cool actually like to see his POV

 

[CrazySteph]

really???

I thought that was kinda cool actually like to see his POV

me too! I thought it was neat to hear the wolfes go back and forth w/ their thoughts.

and how Edward would randomly respond to Jacob's thoughts too.

 

[JulielovesDisney]

Me too.
After this book I like him more.
And Emmett. God, he was hysterical in this book.
Jasper was cool too.

Emmett was hilarious!!! And I absolutely loved Jacob's blonde jokes to Rosalie! I was laughing hysterically at them, and my parents were giving me weird looks. lol

I don't think it sucked.
I think it could have been better, and I was expecting more.
But, it wasn't terrible.

Yeah, there was a lot more she could have touched on.

Entertainment Weekly gave it a D

 

[OneTreeHill]

Emmett was hilarious!!! And I absolutely loved Jacob's blonde jokes to Rosalie! I was laughing hysterically at them, and my parents were giving me weird looks. lol


Yeah, there was a lot more she could have touched on.

Yeah, but like Stephenie said.
Everyone made this book out to be a HUGE thing and xpected so much.
And NO book could have accomplished what everyone wanted this book to do.

Yeah, I was laughing out loud alot, and my sister told me to get a life.

 

[JulielovesDisney]

Yeah, but like Stephenie said.
Everyone made this book out to be a HUGE thing and xpected so much.
And NO book could have accomplished what everyone wanted this book to do.

Yeah, I was laughing out loud alot, and my sister told me to get a life.

Yeah. That's true. I had no idea what to expect, but a few things I just didn't like at all.

But Midnight Sun looks AH-MAY-ZING! lol I'm reading the first chapter right now online. I think it's written so much more eloquently than Twilight (it should be considering it's from Edward's perspective). But I totally love this book all ready.

 

[OneTreeHill]

Yeah. That's true. I had no idea what to expect, but a few things I just didn't like at all.

But Midnight Sun looks AH-MAY-ZING! lol I'm reading the first chapter right now online. I think it's written so much more eloquently than Twilight (it should be considering it's from Edward's perspective). But I totally love this book all ready.

Yeah. There were a few things in Breaking Dawn that I didn't like, but oh well.

OME. Midnight Sun, amazing. I cannot wait. I can't wait to see how the meadow scene and everything come from Edward's perspective.

 

[JulielovesDisney]

Yeah. There were a few things in Breaking Dawn that I didn't like, but oh well.

OME. Midnight Sun, amazing. I cannot wait. I can't wait to see how the meadow scene and everything come from Edward's perspective.

I hope she continues writing the rest of the books through his perspective!! They would be so fascinating! Especially New Moon, then we could see where he goes and how he reacts to Bella's "suicide"! That would be terrific

 

[OneTreeHill]

I hope she continues writing the rest of the books through his perspective!! They would be so fascinating! Especially New Moon, then we could see where he goes and how he reacts to Bella's "suicide"! That would be terrific

Yeah, out of all the books, I would love to see Edward's perspective in New Moon.
I hope she writes them all.

 

[CrazySteph]

Yeah. That's true. I had no idea what to expect, but a few things I just didn't like at all.

But Midnight Sun looks AH-MAY-ZING! lol I'm reading the first chapter right now online. I think it's written so much more eloquently than Twilight (it should be considering it's from Edward's perspective). But I totally love this book all ready.

I read that online chapter too and thought it was so great!!! It was like, even though I already know how its going to turn out, it was like I didn't know all over again..

I think i'm going to like Twilight from Edward's perspective way better.

and did anyone else read the deleted scene in Edward's perspective of when he got the phone call from Rosalie that Bella was dead in New Moon??
well I read that and it was soo great!

 

[OneTreeHill]

I read that online chapter too and thought it was so great!!! It was like, even though I already know how its going to turn out, it was like I didn't know all over again..

I think i'm going to like Twilight from Edward's perspective way better.

and did anyone else read the deleted scene in Edward's perspective of when he got the phone call from Rosalie that Bella was dead in New Moon??
well I read that and it was soo great!

No, I didn't read that.,
Where can you read that?

 

[JulielovesDisney]

I read that online chapter too and thought it was so great!!! It was like, even though I already know how its going to turn out, it was like I didn't know all over again..

I think i'm going to like Twilight from Edward's perspective way better.

and did anyone else read the deleted scene in Edward's perspective of when he got the phone call from Rosalie that Bella was dead in New Moon??
well I read that and it was soo great!

Oh yeah, I'm going to love Edward's version better than the original Twilight too!

And where is the deleted scene or whatever? I haven't finished the first chaper of Midnight Sun yet, is it on there?

 

[CrazySteph]

http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/nm_extras.html

here it is.. It's Rosalie's News