And now Allears has this on their website (Sorry if I missed it already being posted):
"Last week, after the All Ears Newsletter had been mailed, we became aware of an unannounced change in Disney's policy regarding tickets that were purchased from non-Disney sources. Several guests reported that when they attempted to add a day to their Magic your Way ticket that was purchased from a non-Disney source, they were refused and told that they would have to spend more than $100 for a single day ticket. Several tried at both their resort concierge and at a guest relations window and were told the same thing.
We called the Disney Ticketing office and and spoke to a supervisor. We were told that commencing with last week's price increase "3rd party tickets can no longer be upgraded to passes at a pro-rated rate, have days added, or have options added at a discount." A different call to a second Disney source confirmed it but added that this does not affect AAA.
On the basis of that, we changed our ticket FAQ to reflect the new policy. More refinement of the policy will likely become known as time passes. We will keep watching the situation and listening to our readers' comments about any problems or successes they have had in this area. - March 3, 2014"
http://allears.net/pl/ticket.htm#credpass
Again - clear as mud. This all makes no sense even from a business stand point of Disney. If correct we'll head somewhere else rather than pay for a new ticket.
Right - clear as mud. That site's credibility has gone from bad to worse for me.
I used to upgrade those to APs until the price of the 10-day non-expiring hopper was more than the price of an AP - with no change given. Now I will save that ticket for shorter visits to WDW. In the future, I will buy what I need for an upcoming trip from a discounter like UCT. 

I'm very happy with your service, Disney's not so much. 