Interesting....
I had been thinking about dropping down to silver next year when our FL resident Gold AP expires next March. We have discovered we don't spend much time in FL during the summer and could easily shift our time into late August.
I could see how the Theme Park Select option might work for us. As snowbirds our Disney time has morphed into "winter walks enhanced by Disney". We could probably work out a schedule to get to all of the parks. We don't frequently visit the parks on the weekends. And we gave up visiting during the crowded holidays and dropped from Platinum to Gold APs a few years ago. The one item that caught my attention was blocking out Fri/Sat/Sun at Epcot during Food and Wine. That makes it tougher to enjoy the Eat to the Beat concerts. I find the complexity of the black outs a bit annoying. But I understand what Disney is trying to do. Getting ready to control access to Galaxy's Edge.