All personal opinion - I'm not right, you aren't wrong....
We're
DVC members homed at VWL. Been going to AP for a good 12 years, twice per year....
AP experienced what a NUMBER of SIGs went through - they fell off the boat trying to "cut costs" for the
DDP - with the same result: their offerings went into a death spiral. The HBD did this, and recovered. Bistro de Paris did this - changed names, and never recovered. LeCelier really never measured up, and never got better

.
This is seldom the fault of a head chef.... rather, the head chef and current management really MUST work together. AP has always had great Head Chefs.... but sometimes, as with other SIGs - they cooperate TOO much with Management. AP has always had good Managers.... but sometimes, as with other SIGs? They pay attention to DDP cash flow and corporate "team" mentality TOO much, and don't want to listen to the Head Chef

.
If you look closely.... AP, and several OTHER Sigs have pretty much had enough of DDP clipping. And they have come up with a WONDERFUL means of killing this beast
.
"Enhancements"
.
AP, Narcoossee's, Citrico's, The CA Grill - these are only the Disney Owned SIG's that we have had personal experience with, in the last year, that have gone the "Enhancement" route. OTHERS may have.
The strategy is brilliant. It allows a SIG to OFFER enhanced items, without getting into the "DDP financial Clip". Got DDP? No problem - BASIC Entree, etc, etc, etc,

.
Now, with this? We've seen new Managers at AP.... and a new Head Chef. GOOD move - it gets people out of a rut, and lets them THINK differently. The offerings HAVE improved - but are also no longer slaved to a "DDP Clip". Overall? We've booked AP again for the Fall of 2016. If the improvement continues? We'll book 'em again in April 2017

.
Again, All personal opinion - I'm not right, you aren't wrong....