Hmm. Here's an example: I had 3x purchases of $130 to earn $40 in rewards. I already had $30+ in rewards in my account. I went to the store yesterday and did my 3 purchases back-to-back. The first, I had 3 items that totaled $30.6 plus a $100 DGC. Here's the receipt:
View attachment 955556
As you can see, I used my rewards to cover the merch part of the order. The $95 for the GC was paid for with my Circle credit card. This counted toward my bonus. I did my other two transactions, another of which also used rewards as part of the payment. I got notification that I got the $40 rewards before I finished putting stuff back in my cart and I see it in my account.
So now I'm wondering, does this just not work for everyone? Or am I getting mixed up about what you mean by rewards, maybe?