If getting stuck in a preferred room means next to a pool where there is screaming in the wee hours of the morning, than 'darn it' no thanks. And yes, I've been stuck in a room where I couldn't switch, even the next day or the day after....that simple solution is not always an option.
For the record, I'm seldom in the bed (or even in the room) by 12, we close the parks now that my child is older, but I can see where it could be a problem for some. I mean, screaming in the pool at 1 and 2 in the morning...c'mon, seriously?
To get one thing strait, never did I imply that allowing your children in a pool during official hours means you're a bad parent or that your children are heathens....quite a strecth to twist it around like that--YOUR words, not MINE.

I meant exactly what I said...generally speaking...I would hate to think I could not control my children (pool or no pool) and that I shrugged their disruptiveness off as 'kids being kids' and 'something I couldn't change' as it has been mentioned on the board before.
There are many things you are within your right to do at Disney, but because we as humans (some of us) don't try to be purposely rude, we refrain. This, IMO is just another one of those cases.