Granny said:
Like Caskbill, I also hope this is not the impression that people get here. I don't think anyone has claimed that you can't get other resorts at the 7 month mark.
I don't disagree with anything that you said. But let's just say that I think there's an awful lot lost in translation.
People claim that Guides are basically telling them every resort will always have availability at the 7 month window. Frankly, I believe that's true--I bet you could count on one hand the number of times per year where any given resort is 100% booked before the phone lines open at exactly seven months.
The problem is that people either aren't asking the right questions or they are adding their own interpretation to the response. If there is a single room unbooked at 7 months, year round, at all of the resorts, then the responses provided are factually correct. And, frankly, its silly to think that any Disney representative would even be able to address the subtleties of BWV availability (Std View vs. Pref View, popular times of year, etc.) in a factual manner.
Then you've got the other side of the coin. How many times is this Home resort question answered with "buy where you want to stay." To the uninformed, the implication of this statement is pretty simple--if you don't buy where you want to stay, you won't be able to stay there.
IMO, pointing out to people that they won't have sweat-out the reservations until the 7 month window at their Home is very valuable, factual information.
Many of the other comments made are not only confusing to potential members, they are speculative and have little basis in fact.