There are so many great places to choose from. Some of my favorites are:
Artist Pt. at the Wilderness Lodge. The salmon is wonderful and the berry cobbler is to die for. The atmosphere there is really nice and very laid back and a lot quieter than many other resorts.
Flying Fish on the Boardwalk. An excellent seafood restaurant that is expensive but well worth it.
Cape May Buffet at the Beach Club. More than just a seafood buffet. Many, many choices and a great dessert table.
Wolfgang Puck Cafe in Down Town Disney is also a really good place to dine. There are a lot of different selections on the menu.
Kona Kafe at the Poly. We had breakfast there in April and the tonga toast is really, really good. DH also loved the pressed pot of coffee.
We also really enjoy the character breakfasts at Crystal Palace and Cape May.
We love the counter service in Norway for lunch.
My DH and DS love the hot wings at ESPN on the boardwalk.