OK - so this year is my DH's 50th and I am very confused about what kind of a celebration to have. The problem is he is a very social kind of guy - tons of friends, involved in Scouts and very involved in serving at church, plus he has a huge family. I would love to just throw a huge party as I am pretty sure he'd love that, but there is no way I could afford it and we could never fit that many people in our house! So that idea is out.
I've thought alot about doing a (much smaller) surprise party, but in the end decided that he would be just as happy to help plan it. He is very much the one who loves to cook/entertain. So we discussed it and he decided that because a party would be so expensive that we should just invite our two families out to dinner (everyone would pay for themselves as this has been done before and is very acceptable to all) and then we would go spend the night at a local hotel, just the two of us. Now this sounds GREAT to me - but I know deep down this type of celebration is much more what *I* would choose than what HE would and I'm having a hard time letting go of the idea of having a party for him. I did let him talk me out of having a party for him for his 40th and of course he never complained, but I still felt like it was something he would have really enjoyed. He did throw a surprise party for me for my 40th (and invited alot of his (and "our") friends LOL!). That was easily 60 people and didn't even include his family (there are over 40 of us including kids). That was mostly friends from church and that was 6 years ago - and now that list has grown even more since he keeps finding new places to serve!
I suggested to him that we just have a dinner party for our "closest" friends from church (in addition to going out with our families) and he was only luke warm on that idea because he felt it would be very hard to keep the list short and he didn't want to figure out who not to invite...
I was thinking about reserving a room at church and *just* serving cake/coffee/punch - this would be right after a service (and I would make it a surprise), but it seems like there should be food. I ran it by some friends and some felt just cake was fine, some felt I'd need to serve food, esp. since it would be lunch time. I admit I agree with there should be food...
Of course I know I could ask people to bring stuff, but I'm not sure if I'm comfortable with that either. Plus it seems confusing to figure out how to work that with such a big group. Any thoughts on that?
What to do??? I'm feeling inclined to just go with the family dinner and the quiet celebration at this point, but I feel a little sad not to acknowledge this big b-day in a way that really reflects him! He's been talking about "you only turn 50 ONCE" and "I'll be half way to 100!!" for months, so I know it's a big deal to him. I just can't figure out a way to make it special/fun without going broke given his huge circle of friends and family! HELP!
Oh my goodness - I am sorry this got soooo long!!!
I've thought alot about doing a (much smaller) surprise party, but in the end decided that he would be just as happy to help plan it. He is very much the one who loves to cook/entertain. So we discussed it and he decided that because a party would be so expensive that we should just invite our two families out to dinner (everyone would pay for themselves as this has been done before and is very acceptable to all) and then we would go spend the night at a local hotel, just the two of us. Now this sounds GREAT to me - but I know deep down this type of celebration is much more what *I* would choose than what HE would and I'm having a hard time letting go of the idea of having a party for him. I did let him talk me out of having a party for him for his 40th and of course he never complained, but I still felt like it was something he would have really enjoyed. He did throw a surprise party for me for my 40th (and invited alot of his (and "our") friends LOL!). That was easily 60 people and didn't even include his family (there are over 40 of us including kids). That was mostly friends from church and that was 6 years ago - and now that list has grown even more since he keeps finding new places to serve!
I suggested to him that we just have a dinner party for our "closest" friends from church (in addition to going out with our families) and he was only luke warm on that idea because he felt it would be very hard to keep the list short and he didn't want to figure out who not to invite...
I was thinking about reserving a room at church and *just* serving cake/coffee/punch - this would be right after a service (and I would make it a surprise), but it seems like there should be food. I ran it by some friends and some felt just cake was fine, some felt I'd need to serve food, esp. since it would be lunch time. I admit I agree with there should be food...
Of course I know I could ask people to bring stuff, but I'm not sure if I'm comfortable with that either. Plus it seems confusing to figure out how to work that with such a big group. Any thoughts on that?
What to do??? I'm feeling inclined to just go with the family dinner and the quiet celebration at this point, but I feel a little sad not to acknowledge this big b-day in a way that really reflects him! He's been talking about "you only turn 50 ONCE" and "I'll be half way to 100!!" for months, so I know it's a big deal to him. I just can't figure out a way to make it special/fun without going broke given his huge circle of friends and family! HELP!
Oh my goodness - I am sorry this got soooo long!!!
Well, I just got done throwing mine a 40th and it wasn't a surprise because like you I thought he would enjoy planning the party and plus he was such a big help the day of. I was so exhausted at the end of the night after doing all the cooking with MIL. There were about 50 people at a rented hall. In hindsight, I wish I would have chosen a different menu to save on the budget. We served chicken marsala and chicken francese, sausage & peppers, pasta, wine and beer. I should have just ordered pizza and 2 six foot hero's that's the most budget friendly idea I can come up with. Oh well, he enjoyed the party and I told him the next party we throw for him is when he turns 80 
ummm I don't THINK so! She exagerates (sp?) just a little. At least I HOPE so!


! I'm totally gonna do that!