Narcoossees or Citricos or Artist Point?

[TRBelle84]

I'm trying to fill one last dinner spot and it just so happens to be our first night of our trip... We haven't eaten at any of the 3 so I'd love some opinions.

Thanks!

 

[soulmates]

Artist Point was hands down, THE best meal we had last trip. Beautiful restaurant, AMAZING service and FABULOUS food. Our waiter was IZZY and he was really, the most attentive server we've ever had. We'll be back for sure!

 

[MissionMouse]

We have dined at all three at various times over the years and if I were to rank them in the order of perference they would be in the following order:
1. Citricos
2. Narcoossees
3. Artist Pointe

 

[Pakey]

We have also dined at all of the signatures numerous times and I would rank these 3 as follows:

1. Citricos
2. Artist Point
3. Narcoosees

We are an adult only group so my opinions reflect an opinion that combines the food and atmosphere (Narcoosees is a bit casual and too loud to rank higher).

 

[TNMice]

Our order would be:

1) Narcoossees
2) Citricos
3) Artist Point (Only b/c we have never been there!)

MY DH and and I love going to Narcoossees. It's our 'must visit' restaurant every trip. They have consistently good service, great seafood and steak, and I love their desserts (especially the almond cheescake, it's my favorite dessert on property, and let's not forget the pistachio gelato!)

We didn't have as great of a time at Citricos. The server wasn't very attentive, and I found my food lacking of flavor (I had the pork). My DH did love the risotto appetizer!

 

[miko]

My choices in order-
1.Artists Point because of consistantly good food and excellent service.
2. Citrico's great service, excellent wine list, very good food
3. Narcoossees is last because of noise level and unfortunately the last (and I mean last) time the food was about as always (mediocore) but the service was awful.
Of course that is only my opinion.

 

[goofy4prez]

I've tried all three and can't say that I wouldn't return to any of them but my favorites are listed below in order of preference.

1. Narcoossee's (favorite WDW restaurant)
2. Artist Pointe
3. Citricos

 

[squee!! disney!!]

1. narcoossee's (i love their filet mignon and their mussels.)
2. artist point (their cedar plank salmon is delicious!!!)
3. citricos (i know i ate here. i just don't really remember it.)

plus if you eat at narcoossee's during wishes you can see the fireworks! its nice!

 

[PictureJumpr]

I would book Artist Point without hesitation, it's one of my favorites.

I would book Narcoossee's if someone I am travelling with wants to, it is acceptable but not a favorite. Service is spotty, sometimes wonderful but sometimes downright absent, and the food quality is another hit-or-miss. Noise levels do not bother me but I could see how PPs have had issues with it.

I would not book Citrico's. I have given this one no fewer than four tries, but have written it off. We've had good servers (never great, once quite awful) there, but food quality seems consistently un-fabulous, and since there has not been any improvement to speak of in our experiences the last couple of years, it's off the list.

 

[Jungle Cruiser]

1. Narcoossee's
2. Artist Pointe
3. Citricos

Narcoossee's is a favorite, I have never been disappointed in a meal there. The view is of Bay Lake and we love to have coffee and dessert (yes, the almond cheesecake is wonderful!) and watch Wishes from the table. That's Disney magic!

 

[lilonstitch12008]

Citricos!

 

[Silver Queen]

Our choices would be:
1. Citrico's--excellent food and service
2. Narcoosee's--also good service. I loved the Green goddess Salad there but I'm not sure it's still on the menu
3. The salmon was good, but not outstanding, accompaniments were dry, love the ambiance and service here

 

[cbg1027]

I havent been to Artist Point, but Citricos was fantastic and has been consistently the 3 times I've gone. Narcoossee's was just ok.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Narcoossees - Love it
Citricos - Love it
Artist Point- never been but heard all good.

 

[Chevyscool]

MY DH and and I love going to Narcoossees. It's our 'must visit' restaurant every trip. They have consistently good service, great seafood and steak, and I love their desserts (especially the almond cheescake, it's my favorite dessert on property, and let's not forget the pistachio gelato!)

Same with us...we NEVER miss Narcoossee's! We've dined at just about every Signature restaurant and have always had excellent service and enjoyed yummy items (like the Surk and Turf ) at Narcoossee's...it's our favorite restaurant on property!

 

[schatterjee]

I may be alone and we love WL but found Artist Pointe blah - service and food wise. Maybe just an off night or maybe it was just us.