Narcoossee's or California Grill?

[Kariann0]

So I have two ADR's, Narcoossee's and California Grill for the same night. I have to cancel one, but I am on the fence I don't know which one to cancel. Any insights or suggestions? Also, the reservations are for my husband and 2.5 year old daughter, if that makes a difference at either of these places.

Thanks for your input ahead of time!

 

[moobar25]

Narcoossee's all the way! We've been there with our daughter at 3mo, 8mo and now going in sept and she's 2.5. Great food, wonderful staff and everyone was great with our daughter. It's our favorite place to eat.
Cali is good too but we're not all too excited about the new menu since the renovations. But if u do decide to go here ask to be seated with Jenny- the best server ever. Plus her section is wonderful for fireworks!

 

[Kariann0]

I haven't been to Narcoossee's in a very long time, but I always hear good things about California Grill. Hmmm, hoping to get some more opinions. Still undecided. lol

 

[BuzzinDownToDisney]

I say Narcoossee's. I like CG, I love Narcoossee's. We find it a bit more kid friendly as well. However the big difference for me is the food. While CG food is tasty, I rarely feel full leaving there and I'm not a huge eater. Narcoossee's always has the perfect portion sizes of the tastiest meal. Plus Wishes from the deck is really cool.

 

[Kariann0]

Wow I think I am really leaning towards Narcoossee's. I have an ADR in Jan for California Grill and I am thinking of maybe switching to Narcoossee's again lol.

 

[Polish Hammer]

We did both places last trip to WDW. We are going back again this year and CG was a must do ADR while nobody in the family wanted to go back to Narcooossees. The trip over on the boat was nice, walking around the resort was nice, the food was OK and nothing was bad at all, just nothing we felt compelled to try again. CG on the other hand was superb all around.