My picture...question

[Luv0fDisney]

Okay.
i need your opinion....
this is the same picture, except one has been photo shopped - not going to mention which one.

which picture looks better

version a...might be original...might be photoshopped

or

version b...might be original...might be photoshopped

I will let everyone know which is which after people vote in posts

 

[KCmike]

First one is better. Better contrast and saturation but maybe a little overdone. Not sure if the photo is in focus either? Seems a little off.

 

[photo_chick]

The first one looks better overall but to me still has some pretty big issues.

"Photoshopped" usually implies more than just basic editing/processing. IN that respect I'd say neither have really been photoshopped. But the first one has a look that suggests it may have been processed a bit much.

 

[Gianna'sPapa]

Like the others, the first "looks" better, but appears out of focus. the 'B' version is over exposed and could have used a polarizing filter to cut down the glare.

 

[havoc315]

Agree with others... First is better, second is blown out. I don't think the focus is really so bad, but perhaps stopping down the aperture may have sharpened it up a bit.

 

[wiigirl]

Agree....definetly the first one.

 

[Luv0fDisney]

thanks. the first one is the photoshoped one.