My opinion of ASMo and Pop Century as 1st timers

luvitmoreachtime

Mouseketeer
Joined
Sep 10, 2004
Messages
130
We hated staying at the value resorts. The Pop Century was better than the ASMo but not much. It was like staying at a cheap hotel with Disney themes. Nice place to visit to take pictures but I would never want to stay there again. We have always had a condo in the past and even though we did not like the Westgate Resort last year, we would stay there over a value any day. The parking situation is horrible. You will be parking the equivalent of 3 blocks from your room. After spending an entire day walking the park, you will have more walking to do when you get to your room. We are use to parking right outside of our door so this was aggravating. To add insult to injury, the week we were there, the hotel closed two parking lots closest to our room and was planning to close the one in the next section too. If you dont plan on using your car at all, this may be ok but we also thought the buses were crowd and very inconvenient especially if you have small kids and a stroller. Even if you don't, plan on getting up close and personal with someone elses stroller, lol. Our room did not smell the best and the housekeeping was questionable. The Pop Century was newer and therefore cleaner and not quite as crowd but it still was like staying in a cheap motel.
We didnt think the food was very good at the food court and they did not do a very good job of keeping the tables clean. We had to bus our table and wipe it down with babywipes before sitting down every time we ate there.
We loved the parks but I cant imagine staying onsite again unless its the GF and we would only book for a night or two to try it out the first time.
 
Yikes! That's too bad that you didn't like the value resorts. I was planning on staying at Pop this January, but my parents want to go Deluxe, so Deluxe it is. We've stayed at Contemporary and WL before and loved them. I've never stayed at a value and frankly, I'm a little leary after hearing many poor comments about them.

Give onsite another chance. I've heard great things about the moderates and many of the deluxes.

Glad to hear you loved the parks though!!:wave2:
 
The Mods are much nicer and IMO its worth the little extra $$ per night. POFQ is really nice as is POR. and with a code it could cost the same.
Dont give up on on-site yet try a mod. resort first.
 
you did not enjoy your stays at the values. Always a disappointment to read that.

We have stayed in mods, values and one deluxe (WL). We are park people (2 adults) and spent little time in our rooms anyway.
I can say I have had just as good stays in values as I have the deluxe. But all were pretty darn good and had plus and minuses.

I will note to anyone who wants a hotel room where their car is right outside their door, or even very close, then a WDW resort is not for them.
It's a big place with big resorts and a lot of walking. ::yes::
 
i can see that that parking would be the same anywhere in the resorts and thats why I think that we would only stay onsite if we could stay at a deluxe with monorail service at the front door. We really did not like the buses but this is just a personal opinion. Tons of people use them and love them. We just did not find them more convenient and they were just too crowded even off season.
 
deluxe with monorail service at the front door.
Totally agree -- esp with kids in tow.
I have not stayed at the monorail resorts.
Just walking and riding through the resorts has made me wonder if those staying in outer buildings really benefit from staying at a monorail resort. :confused:
Some of the buildings at the Poly are quite a way from the main building. Depending on the room, the TTC seems closer than the main building.
I have always wondered if guests have been disappointed not staying in the main buildings of the monorial resorts.
 
I wondered about that too. it looks like monorail resorts are only good if you are in the main building and I bet you pay a premium to get this. I just think we enjoyed our vacation more when we could leave the parks behind us and go "home" or our temporary home for a quiet evening. We also got very tired of french fries with every meal and what felt like fast food all the time. I dont like to cook on vacation but some nice steamed veggies would have been good after a few days of fried foods. I'm not down on WDW. I loved the park and we had more wonderful firsts this visit then ever. Like first time in the front of the monorail, first ride on the fire truck and the horse drawn street car and we got autographed balloon as last person in line for characters at MGM, the only downside of vacation was the hotel and the rude, Non-American tourists, oh, and the unwelcomed guest, Jeanne.

I know i'll take some flaming replies on the rude tourist comment but I hated the way that non English speaking tourists used this as an excuse for not following the rules and for cutting in lines. I had a Hispanic woman trample my two year old daughter trying to get to Mickey Mouse with here grandkids and she never stopped and never attempted an apology. She continued to step on her even after she cried out and I had to shove her off my daughter. I was furious and she went along like she never knew it happened. Americans have a reputation for being bad tourist in foreign countries but we can not possibly be any worse than they are when they come here!
 
We hated staying at the value resorts
It was like staying at a cheap hotel
I would never want to stay there again
The parking situation is horrible
this was aggravating
the buses were crowd and very inconvenient
plan on getting up close and personal with someone elses stroller
Our room did not smell the best and the housekeeping was questionable
We didnt think the food was very good at the food court
they did not do a very good job of keeping the tables clean
I cant imagine staying onsite again unless its the GF

:scratchin
 
I know what I said. I wanted feedback not just my own words quoted back with no input. What are you trying to say?
 
Originally posted by luvitmoreachtime
We hated staying at the value resorts. The Pop Century was better than the ASMo but not much. It was like staying at a cheap hotel with Disney themes. Nice place to visit to take pictures but I would never want to stay there again. We have always had a condo in the past and even though we did not like the Westgate Resort last year, we would stay there over a value any day. The parking situation is horrible. You will be parking the equivalent of 3 blocks from your room. After spending an entire day walking the park, you will have more walking to do when you get to your room. We are use to parking right outside of our door so this was aggravating. To add insult to injury, the week we were there, the hotel closed two parking lots closest to our room and was planning to close the one in the next section too. If you dont plan on using your car at all, this may be ok but we also thought the buses were crowd and very inconvenient especially if you have small kids and a stroller. Even if you don't, plan on getting up close and personal with someone elses stroller, lol. Our room did not smell the best and the housekeeping was questionable. The Pop Century was newer and therefore cleaner and not quite as crowd but it still was like staying in a cheap motel.
We didnt think the food was very good at the food court and they did not do a very good job of keeping the tables clean. We had to bus our table and wipe it down with babywipes before sitting down every time we ate there.
We loved the parks but I cant imagine staying onsite again unless its the GF and we would only book for a night or two to try it out the first time.



I don't mean to be rude but if GF is the only onsite resort that interested you then why did you choose POP?? How can you make a blanket statement about not wanting to stay anywhere else onsite when you have never tried any of the other resorts?? You do know that you are in the minority to prefer to stay offsite rather than onsite. What type of feedback were you looking for? Your views are going to be in the minority on an onsite resort board. Very interesting post. It's very telling.
 
I dont think I am in the minority. I think I am in the minority on this message board. My comment was based on the fact that we looked at the other moderate resorts and they are still reliant on the bus transportation and that was not appealing. The GF appeared to be the nicest of the Deluxe resorts on the monorail system and that is why I said that is the only one we would have chosen. What does it tell you that we would prefer to stay off site to a value resort, since it is so "telling". What does it "tell" me that you wouldn't. Not to be "rude" though.........
 
Since I was referring to these boards as far as you being in the minority then I guess you just confirmed my statement!! As far as all of your other statements, I get the feeling you are looking for someone else to encourage and approve of your views. You have responded to most of the responses on here. I caught the point that Pea-N-Me was making. If you don't want to stay at WDW resorts then don't. It really doesn't matter one way or another to me. Obviously many people do like to stay there or I would be able to get the resort of my choice next weekend but because it is so booked I can't.
 
Wow, we just got back from Pop last week and had just about the opposite experience you did. We had a great time, mousekeeping kept the room nice and clean, it was very quiet, and since we stayed in the preferred 60's building we had a rather short walk to the dining hall and to our vehicle in the lot across from the buses. We brought our own stroller and did not find it very inconvenient at all, even with our toddler in tow. Sure, it took a second, or maybe a second and a half, to break down the stroller and carry it onto the bus, but hardly inconvenient. It was a bit of a tight squeeze to get the stroller through the door into the room, but we had a good laugh about it. We found the buses came often, we rarely had to wait for more than 10 minutes for one to arrive. *shrug* I've stayed in plenty of 'cheap' motels and this hardly felt like one of those...

I guess it depends what you're used to, we rarely pop for expensive hotels because we only sleep and shower and we're out the door and don't come back until it's time to sleep again;) So we don't really have the need for the extra amenities you pay for at the 'better' resorts. I'm sure if we needed those we would look into a mod or deluxe. Maybe sometime way in the future:D
 
All of the WDW resorts rely on bus service to at least a couple of the parks. The monorail only gets you to Epcot and MK, to get to the other resorts you still have to take a bus. Also, many of the counter service places in the parks offer carrots as a side item instead of fries, and Tusker House in AK has lots of other choices besides burgers and fries. They offer rotisserie chicken, wraps, steamed veggies, etc. Also, in MK Columbia Harbour House has other offerings, as do many stops in Epcot. I really didn't enjoy POP either when we were there in August, but we've always had good stays at ASMo. The only reason we didn't really care for PC was because we didn't feel the Disney theming there. (I know it's not supposed to be Disney themed, that's why we liked ASMo better). We just came back from a night at CBR, and the difference between it and PC was like night and day. It doesn't have to be a deluxe to make it nicer than the values. We are going to try WL in Dec. though for my dd's birthday. I can't wait to see it decorated for Christmas! Sorry you didn't enjoy your stay, maybe it's just that you're used to more space in the condo?
 
well we stayed at pop in february and we will be staying there again in december and we could stay at any of the resorts we would like but like others we are not in our rooms alot..our children and ourselves would much rather be in the parks or somewhere...so we go cheap on the room and spend elsewhere.....i am sorry you had such a horrible experience at pop..we think it rocks and will stay there again and again...
 
I'm not a fan of the value resorts for many of the reasons the OP gave. But, HAHAHA if they think they will be closer to their car in guest self parking at the GF. The GF valet service is also about the worst of any WDW deluxe resort.

The best place to have your car right outside your door is OKW.

And I'll stop this post now before I get in trouble.

Anne
 
We have stayed at POP twice already and our experience was totally different from yours (We also stayed at ASMO 2X and ASSP 2X and those times we enjoyed our stay). Sorry that your stay was ugly, that's too bad.

I really don't have any advice or suggestion, I just wanted to say that staying on-sight beats staying off-sight, of course your opinion is different from mine.

You won't be a minority if you post this on the other board, most folks there prefer staying off-sight and there sure is nothing wrong with that.
 
started to get hot there for a minute, i think somebody needs a nap.
 
We didn't enjoy our POP stay either, for many of the same reasons, but we will always stay onsite, and not at a deluxe either. The parking wasn't bad when we were there, we were able to park relatively close, so the monorail
appeal isnt enough for us to pay that much, quite yet.

I really encourage you to check out some moderates the next time you go... they are great, IMO, and worth teh extra few dollars a night =)
 
Ok just from what ive read the value seem like a standard hotel room with two double beds, am i wrong, are they smaller?
From my research ive found that basically value resorts are there for people who only want to nap at day and sleep at night otherwise they are not really meant as comfort...
From my research moderates are only slightly bigger and thus present mainly the same as the value with better outside scenery.
Value resorts offer value food atleast disneys version of value foods, for better quality meals take busses to deluxe resorts or your car...
Parking does sound like a nightmare to me and a hassle thus mainly forcing or atleast tempting guests to use disney transportation after a long day in the park i wouldnt want a long walk to my room either but thats what disney resorts offer, i guess to enhance thqat disney magic of being secluded and part of all that disney has to offer( but im still getting a rental).

Disney is what you make of it in my opinion if you look to find fault , you'll probably find it but with a complex as big as disney world it seems to me they have done there best to accommodate all variety of people they can. Can a cheaper hotel in orlando just as nice as the value resorts be found id say undoubtably yet, but to get that lil bit of magic, the magic that comes from a family and their first vacation to WDW, the feeling of being a park of the disney resort structure with the "disney benefits" that come with staying onsite ill be keeping my reservation at the POP and not sweating the small stuff enjoying my vacation.

Ive stayed at some very nice hotels around the US, and some cheap hotels around the US and the saying "you get what you pay for" doesnt hold true every hotel has risk involved, every hotel is cleaned by people, and even cleaning crews have bad days, sorry your stay at POP wasnt what you had hoped for and i hope my stay which is soon has better results but i too am hoping to grasp a lil disney magic and hope my family's vacation dreams come true.

Im not down on disney as this post may seem, ive read non-disney fans describe values as motels with pretty although sometimes tacky scenery.... ill be looking for the magic in two weeks and in no way regret my choice to stay onsite but ive researched my vacation read every review from the best to the worst and determined onsite is for me( tripadvisor and me have gotten close).
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom