Ok so I had to give up and book the Swan. It was that or sleep in the airport. LOL! Since there is no beach or pool bar there, my options were severely limited. I got the Swan for $189 a night. Not bad at all considering we pay more then twice that for the Poly when we stay there. The pool at the Swan looks amazing and we look forward to hanging out at it every day!! Thanks for all the suggestions ladies!
There is a beach at the swan/dolphin with chaise lounges, hammocks and a playgound. Also the Grotto pool that is shared by the resorts is beautiful.
No swim up pool bar but they both have "poolside bars" where you can get food and drinks.
I think you'll enjoy it.