We've done the Potato Head thing on our last 3 trips, and only once got a new potato. The first time we did it they only had separate arms that were holding Disney things like Mickey Ice creams, autograph books, pens, cameras and the like as well as WDW flip flops, mickey glasses mickey ears and oen or two other things. Slim selection. The last two years they have really expanded their selection! Wow! You can get a little mermaid tail & wig, tink wings, a zillion different kinds of character costumes & hats, plus new arms, eyes, and normal parts in either 'regular' or Disney. In Dec 05 the box was $16.99 plus tax and all three trips the box had to 'close' but each time the cast members checking us out had a different idea of what 'close' meant. 2002 the CM said it meant the tops touched, 2004 the CM said you could still hold it by the handles even if they didn't touch, 2005 the CM said it had to actually fold and close at the top. In 2004 we also did the Lincoln Logs and the CM there said closed meant closed. I noticed in 2005 that near the Potato head area was a display on the wall with pre bagged Disney acessories. I saw it on the way out of the store though and didn't check the price.