Considering you are quoting my post and therefore responding to what I said, I don't recall saying it was a way to "scrimp and save". Just wanted to point that out.
What I don't understand is why is it that only some jobs are automatically deemed tip-worthy simply because of the job and not for going "above and beyond" that job? It completely boggles me mind.
Jessica -
I would bet that you're not the only one who wonders that. In fact, I would bet that a lot of people just don't think about tipping or leaving money each day when they head out to the parks for their adventures. Or they may intend to and then not remember to do it. Or they may look in their wallet and only see $20 bills, and not want to take the time to go buy something to break a $20. Maybe some people just don't even feel it's necessary. I'm fairly positive that some of my well-traveled friends do not think to tip housekeeping daily at whichever hotel they choose - they probably do it only if they have to make a special request or there is a special circumstance.
I think that in certain situations, people instinctively
know to tip (like if a bell guy carries bags or brings them up to the room, or a waiter brings them food), but in other situations, like leaving money for a person they will most likely never come face to face with, they may not know to do it or think it's needed. I don't judge them or look down on anyone who doesn't tip the housekeeping staff, for whatever their reason. I think it's a personal choice. The maids will leave extra bath products each day anyway. They will come in and clean the room and make the beds anyway.
Personally, I feel much better when I leave money for the housekeeping staff each day. (Then again, I have been known to give the Bell Desk guy $10 to take 2 bags from me, and the Domino's driver a $10 tip when he brought pizza.) And I, personally, don't leave a huge mess - on my last DLR trip, only one bed was slept in but I still tipped them $4/$5 daily to cover two beds. But if a situation came up in which I didn't have a small enough bill to leave for them and I was on my way to do something else specific, I can't guarantee that I would go out of my way to go break a larger bill to get a smaller bill, to then come back to the room and leave a tip. I would love to say that I would do that, but I am being honest and saying that I may not...and I would bet that many other people in that same situation would not do it, either!