Mother drives van full of kids into ocean

Make that 4 little ones... this woman is pregnant. :sad2:

It's such a tragic story and I'm curious to find out what her mental state was prior to driving her van into the Atlantic. I've heard her sister's 911 call where she mentioned to the dispatcher that she was talking about the house being filled with demons, etc. and wouldn't be surprised if she has an underlying mental illness. That doesn't excuse what she did though.

I obviously don't know the details about this woman's situation, but if she is mentally ill to the point of thinking her house is full of demons, I do think it "excuses" what she has done. Someone who is out of touch with reality to that extent may genuinely believe that killing her children will save them from the demons or something similar - she may have not been trying to harm them, but to help them (in her delusional view). I see absolutely no value in punishing someone like that.

There was a case in my town in which a mother became convinced that her children's toys contained devils and evil spirits and these had taken possession of the children. She eventually concluded that she had to kill the children to free them from these evil spirits and thought that once she had done this, they would come back to life but the devils would be gone. But people like this can often seem relatively normal in other ways - they can develop a plan and take steps to make sure their plans are not interrupted. They are just not in touch with reality.

TP
 
No, it didn't excuse what she did, but I can't help but feel bad for her. She obviously has some mental illness and thankfully no one was hurt.

I knew a friend of a friend who suffered from PPD and started hearing demons and started having thoughts of harming her baby. Fortunately, her husband was able to see what was going on and convinced her to check into a mental hospital. She stayed there for two weeks while being treated for PPD. Had she not taken her husbands advice and refused to seek treatment, who knows what she would have done to her baby.
Mental illness is a very sensitive issue and for those who don't have a srtong support system around them it can be very hard to get help.

Thankfully is right.

This lady needs help and her family recognizes that, she may even recognize that as she went voluntarily checked herself into a mental health ward on Monday but backed out at the last second. I've worked with people with severe mental illnesses since I started working as a nurse and have seen first hand how debilitating these diseases can be.
 
Right. What if the police had just detained her and taken her children away? People would be complaining about how mentally ill people are treated badly by "the system".

It's easy to look at how the situation ended and say she shouldn't have left that police stop with the kids but she hadn't done anything illegal with them at that point so the police couldn't do anything.

Can you imagine the uproar if police could just send you for a psychiatric hold or take your kids away because someone called in a tip?

I agree, its a very very fine line.
 
I obviously don't know the details about this woman's situation, but if she is mentally ill to the point of thinking her house is full of demons, I do think it "excuses" what she has done. Someone who is out of touch with reality to that extent may genuinely believe that killing her children will save them from the demons or something similar - she may have not been trying to harm them, but to help them (in her delusional view). I see absolutely no value in punishing someone like that.

There was a case in my town in which a mother became convinced that her children's toys contained devils and evil spirits and these had taken possession of the children. She eventually concluded that she had to kill the children to free them from these evil spirits and thought that once she had done this, they would come back to life but the devils would be gone. But people like this can often seem relatively normal in other ways - they can develop a plan and take steps to make sure their plans are not interrupted. They are just not in touch with reality.

TP

She was in touch with reality enough to know to lie to the police when they stopped her. Clearly on some level she knew what she was doing was wrong. I hope they charge her with attempted murder and she gets convicted.
 
She was in touch with reality enough to know to lie to the police when they stopped her. Clearly on some level she knew what she was doing was wrong. I hope they charge her with attempted murder and she gets convicted.

I saw Dr Drew show (I think that's the show I was watching) talking about this last night and a Dr on the show said that it seems there is paranoid schizophrenia involved here and that she has seen really smart schizophrenic patients protect their delusions very well so that you might not know the person was ill and she suspects this lady is one of those. All conjecture but I thought it worth mentioning.
 
She was in touch with reality enough to know to lie to the police when they stopped her. Clearly on some level she knew what she was doing was wrong. I hope they charge her with attempted murder and she gets convicted.

My understanding of these kinds of mental illnesses is different than yours, I guess. People who have these delusions can seem quite rational in other ways. I don't know the details, but she may have believed that the police were under the control of the demons and so she had to lie to them in order to get her children to 'safety' (in her mind, killing them to protect them). It was not that she knew that what she was doing something that was wrong, but that she knew people (evil people, in her delusional state) might try to stop her from doing something she believed was right, even essential.

I see absolutely no benefit to sending someone with this kind of mental illness to jail. It won't help her - she clearly needs to be in a hospital. It won't deter other mentally ill people from doing the same thing. So what is the point?

TP
 
I see absolutely no benefit to sending someone with this kind of mental illness to jail. It won't help her - she clearly needs to be in a hospital. It won't deter other mentally ill people from doing the same thing. So what is the point?

TP

I agree with you. If she does in fact have a true mental illness, then jail time won't help her in any way. She needs to be put in a mental facility where she can be properly evaluated and treated, and kept away from her children for the time being.
 
Right. What if the police had just detained her and taken her children away? People would be complaining about how mentally ill people are treated badly by "the system".

It's easy to look at how the situation ended and say she shouldn't have left that police stop with the kids but she hadn't done anything illegal with them at that point so the police couldn't do anything.

Can you imagine the uproar if police could just send you for a psychiatric hold or take your kids away because someone called in a tip?

Yup, it's a lose-lose scenario.
 
I agree with you. If she does in fact have a true mental illness, then jail time won't help her in any way. She needs to be put in a mental facility where she can be properly evaluated and treated, and kept away from her children for the time being.

So then you foresee a point at which she should actually be given these kids back? :faint:
 
I agree with you. If she does in fact have a true mental illness, then jail time won't help her in any way. She needs to be put in a mental facility where she can be properly evaluated and treated, and kept away from her children for the time being.
Is it possible she's someone like Andrea Yates? Wasn't she fixated on the devil/demon thing? Isn't she in prison? I think they can treat someone while at the same time have some legal consequences for multiple attempted murder. (Or in Yate's case, actual murder.)

If she is treated and eventually released, gosh, those poor kids. On the one hand she's mommy. On the other, they would probably feel like they had to live/visit with a stalker. How would they ever sleep?

Thank heaven for the good Samaritans. Due to them, the kids have a second chance at life. :thumbsup2 Let's hope that social workers/lawyers/courts are mindful that if there is a next time the kids might not be so lucky. :sad2:
 
So then you foresee a point at which she should actually be given these kids back? :faint:

Yes. I'm not excusing what she did. It was truly horrible.

I think the courts should take away the children while the mother seeks treatment. If whatever illness she has can be properly treated, than she has every right to be givin a second chance with her children. But to say that she should never get to see her children again because she is mentally ill is a bit extreme and harsh.
 
Yes. I'm not excusing what she did. It was truly horrible.

I think the courts should take away the children while the mother seeks treatment. If whatever illness she has can be properly treated, than she has every right to be givin a second chance with her children. But to say that she should never get to see her children again because she is mentally ill is a bit extreme and harsh.

But if she was expert enough at covering he illness such a short time prior to the incident, how would you EVER know she was truly "better"? And it seems to me that even if she was "better" it would just be cruel to put those kids back into the hands of someone they had to wonder about from this point forward.
 
We had a similar case here in Iowa a few years ago.

In December of 2007, a van driven by a mom and her two sons skidded off the road in Iowa City and into the freezing Iowa River. Four bystanders saw this happen and rescued the mom and the two boys, ages 6 and 1. At the time, it was a happy, feel-good story, perfect for the holiday season.

Little did we know that less than a year later, in October, 2008, that same mother would take the boys to a rural area, place duct tape over their eyes, nose, and mouth, and slash both of their necks, killing the younger boy. She then tried to slash her own throat, and later ran to a nearby house, claiming to have been attacked by an unknown man.

In court testimony during the mother's first degree murder trial, she admitted that the river incident the prior year was a suicide attempt, but no one recognized it at the time.

Here is the entire account:

http://murderpedia.org/female.K/k/kehoe-michelle.htm
 
Is it possible she's someone like Andrea Yates? Wasn't she fixated on the devil/demon thing? Isn't she in prison? I think they can treat someone while at the same time have some legal consequences for multiple attempted murder. (Or in Yate's case, actual murder.)

If she is treated and eventually released, gosh, those poor kids. On the one hand she's mommy. On the other, they would probably feel like they had to live/visit with a stalker. How would they ever sleep?

Thank heaven for the good Samaritans. Due to them, the kids have a second chance at life. :thumbsup2 Let's hope that social workers/lawyers/courts are mindful that if there is a next time the kids might not be so lucky. :sad2:

Right. This my my thinking behind saying she needs to be charged with attempted murder and convicted. Don't most states have a guilty with mental illness verdict that would allow her to get treatment and be held legally responsible for her actions?

She needs to be put away somewhere where those children don't have to worry that mommy is going to go off her medication and finish what she started.
 
We had a similar case here in Iowa a few years ago.

In December of 2007, a van driven by a mom and her two sons skidded off the road in Iowa City and into the freezing Iowa River. Four bystanders saw this happen and rescued the mom and the two boys, ages 6 and 1. At the time, it was a happy, feel-good story, perfect for the holiday season.

Little did we know that less than a year later, in October, 2008, that same mother would take the boys to a rural area, place duct tape over their eyes, nose, and mouth, and slash both of their necks, killing the younger boy. She then tried to slash her own throat, and later ran to a nearby house, claiming to have been attacked by an unknown man.

In court testimony during the mother's first degree murder trial, she admitted that the river incident the prior year was a suicide attempt, but no one recognized it at the time.

Here is the entire account:

http://murderpedia.org/female.K/k/kehoe-michelle.htm

Oh my, there are no words. How horrible. :sad2::sad2:
 
My MIL was paranoid schizophrenic. I have seen her in psychosis and medicated. She passed away this past Sept.

We were able to talk to her about her psychotic moments in time. The way she described those times was that she was in a "black out" state. Large chucks of her memory were missing in her life.

Even medicated it is really hard for me to have this person in the care of those children unsupervised.

If she is pregnant she is probably off of all her meds.

And yes, in general schizophrenics are highly intelligent people and know what to say and when to get out of things even in psychosis.

A police officer is not be the person to make a determination of someone's mental state. They are there to uphold the laws, right or wrong as it may appear.
 
Is it possible she's someone like Andrea Yates? Wasn't she fixated on the devil/demon thing? Isn't she in prison? I think they can treat someone while at the same time have some legal consequences for multiple attempted murder. (Or in Yate's case, actual murder.)

I wasn't familiar with the Yates story. I googled it and it looks like even though she was initially sentenced to life in prison, that was overturned and she has been in a high security mental hospital ever since then. And boy did she have a long history of mental illness and PPD episodes.

It's hard. Part of me does think just lock them up in jail and throw away the key. But the other part of me knows that they are mentally ill and do deserve treatment, like any other health issue out there.
 
We had a similar case here in Iowa a few years ago.

In December of 2007, a van driven by a mom and her two sons skidded off the road in Iowa City and into the freezing Iowa River. Four bystanders saw this happen and rescued the mom and the two boys, ages 6 and 1. At the time, it was a happy, feel-good story, perfect for the holiday season.

Little did we know that less than a year later, in October, 2008, that same mother would take the boys to a rural area, place duct tape over their eyes, nose, and mouth, and slash both of their necks, killing the younger boy. She then tried to slash her own throat, and later ran to a nearby house, claiming to have been attacked by an unknown man.

In court testimony during the mother's first degree murder trial, she admitted that the river incident the prior year was a suicide attempt, but no one recognized it at the time.

Here is the entire account:

http://murderpedia.org/female.K/k/kehoe-michelle.htm


There really are no words. :sad2: How horrible for those kids. And that is a very topical story when looking at this recent incident. It really is case in point why the mother should never have custody of those kids ever again. Regardless of what happens with her legally.

I wasn't familiar with the Yates story. I googled it and it looks like even though she was initially sentenced to life in prison, that was overturned and she has been in a high security mental hospital ever since then. And boy did she have a long history of mental illness and PPD episodes.

It's hard. Part of me does think just lock them up in jail and throw away the key. But the other part of me knows that they are mentally ill and do deserve treatment, like any other health issue out there.

We can discuss what her treatment/punishment needs to be. But she should NEVER have unrestricted access to those kids ever again.
 
Oh my, there are no words. How horrible. :sad2::sad2:

The surviving son, who was 8 at the time, had to testify in court that his mommy cut him and hurt his little brother.

We personally know this family. The son, as you can imagine, has had significant struggles with PTSD, anxiety, and depression.
 
I wasn't familiar with the Yates story. I googled it and it looks like even though she was initially sentenced to life in prison, that was overturned and she has been in a high security mental hospital ever since then. And boy did she have a long history of mental illness and PPD episodes.

It's hard. Part of me does think just lock them up in jail and throw away the key. But the other part of me knows that they are mentally ill and do deserve treatment, like any other health issue out there.

Nothing wrong with treatment. But, to not have legal consequences is to say what happened to the kids was a "mistake?" "accident?"

We know better. It was intentional. Maybe due to mental illness, but the children were very close to being deliberately drowned. They need to be safe and protected, period. Mom's possible illness and needs cannot be the primary issue.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom