Our waitress did come back just after our apps were delivered to the table when we were able to ask for drink refills, as well as glasses of ice water, because our drinks were dry at that point. She apologized for the empties, said she'd get our refills immediately...and again she scurried off without taking our entree order. We thought she was going to hurry back with our refills, but no. We did get our drinks after about 10 more minutes, but delivered by a food-runner…which was good, because we were seriously thirsty after the hot morning...but bad because by now we really wanted to get our entree orders in...really did not want to spend the whole afternoon in the restaurant. While the crowd had thinned, it was still very loud in there. Waitress did come back a minute or so after the drink refills were delivered, and she took our entree orders at that point...which then took quite a long time to get out to us - almost 1/2 an hour. Who knew Tony's on Main Street was supposed to be a "fine dining-signature experience"? At least the timing on food ordering & delivery qualified it that way, lol.
Yoda chose the “Shrimp Scampi Linguini with Sun-dried Tomatoes and Asparagus tossed in a Garlic Sauce $16.99” Huge bowl, way too much for lunch, for sure, especially after appetizers. Yoda mostly just picked out the shrimp (was about a dozen good-sized shrimps in that bowl.) Pasta was good, cooked al dente, but much too much on a hot, hot day. The garlic bread on this dish was still in the "bread" stage...crusty on the outside, drenched with garlic butter inside. Tasty, but perhaps too heavy for a hot-day lunch.
Kermie chose the “Panini of the Day," described as pastrami that day. It was served on warm Italian roll…crisp crust with soft bread inside, piled high with roast-beef-like pastrami. It was served with a dill pickle and dish of cole slaw, for $12.99. The sandwich was very large, delicious, but the cole slaw was
hot - yuck! Now we weren't sure if it was supposed to be that way...some places serve hot potato salad so maybe Italians like hot cole slaw? By the time the waitress came back to our table to ask how was the food, Kermie had finished the sandwich ...and we were informed the cole slaw is supposed to be cold. But Kermie was getting full, and didn’t care for more cole slaw so we declined the offer of fresh cole slaw (besides, would probably have taken 15 minutes to get it!) The pickle that came with the sandwich was not hot, so apparently the cole slaw sat under the heat lamp but the pickle did not?
I chose the “Chicken Florentine Calzone: calzone pastry stuffed with Chicken, Spinach, Caramelized Onions, and Mozzarella $13.99" Sorry, I didn’t think to take a picture of the insides, lol. It was full of gooey-mozzarella goodness…lots of chicken & cheese with just enough spinach and onion to lend a bit of flavor. Must say, the outside of the pastry was sprinkled with mozzarella…and salt. As in:
way too much salt…I ended up scraping off the toasted mozzarella and that took most of the salt with it, so the rest was very edible.
The marinara sauce was a tad sweet for my tastes.
Again, it was probably 10 minutes after we finished eating before we saw our waitress again -- by which time we’d stacked our plates in the corner of the table and someone else walking by had cleared them off for us. She did apologize for the delay again, and took our orders. We were surprised that the desserts were actually out quickly…no more than 5 minutes later, which was nice because we were getting tired and fussy...time for our naps, lol.
Yoda chose this awesome pistachio crème brulee for $5.99…delicate pistachio flavor in a good creamy custard with a nicely-carmelized top. One of his favorite crème brulees. That little bit on the side of the plate was like a carmelized-sugar wafer cup, with a couple of bites of strawberry & some sugared pistachios. The strawberry & nuts were good but the little cup thingy just tasted like over-burnt sugar...pretty to look at, but not really for eating.
Kermie went for the "Spumoni: Layers of Ice Cream with Pistachio Nuts and Cherries $4.99” This actually was quite a large slab of ice cream, and served with a couple of cookies. The cookies were nothing to write home about, straight out of a package, probably. But the ice cream was wonderful: the flavors were lemon, pistachio and chocolate. This creamy-smooth ice cream was LOADED with maraschino cherries (you can see one in the chocolate portion) The cherries were throughout all three flavors of ice cream, as well as a sprinkling of nuts. Kermie loved this dessert.
My choice was the "Tiramisu': Espresso-soaked Lady Fingers, Whipped Mascarpone,and Dark Chocolate Shavings $6.49." Don’t know if they always serve it with the “celebrate” and sprinkles or if this was served this way because of our anniversary but it was a pretty touch. The tiramisu was absolutely scrumptious…rich, creamy and totally decadent! Only thing I didn’t like was the “chocolate shavings” on top…I swear that stuff was the fakey pretzel-dip candy (I.e., not really chocolate) I left that on the plate…but cleaned up the tirimisu!
Overall, we enjoyed most of our food at Tony’s, though there were certainly issues. This place gets a bad rap quite often…I guess I can see where that comes from. There were several things wrong in our experience: Tony’s seems to have an extra loud atmosphere, very slow service (nearly an hour & a half for a lunch...when we arrived after the main lunch rush?), and then the little oddities with the food like the hot cole slaw, excess salt on the calzone, and using the fake-chocolate shavings on an otherwise elegant dessert ? Not bad enough to ruin our meal, but I can see how a few more errors would have tipped the balance for us…at Disney prices, you tend to expect at least well-prepared/well-served foods. I do know the guy at the next table was also not happy with his meal -- had been arguing quietly with his waitress, and as we were leaving a manager-type was headed towards that table…so I’m thinking the service/food issues were not unique to us. We're pretty easy-going people, and don't stress enough to complain very often. This experience just wasn't bad enough for us to make a snit, but not a place I'd brag about, either.
Would we return? Maybe…though we'd probably try it for dinner one night instead of lunch again. Just pretty sure the lunch was not worth those $$$ though, especially when you‘re looking for a relaxed table service meal. With the noise level in there, you‘re not getting much of a break from the crowded-park atmosphere...and well I guess if you could nap between courses it could be relaxing, lol. I’d give Tony’s a 6.5 out of 10, better than average, but no danger of being great. The cash total for the 3 meals would have been $101.92...but of course that was covered by the DxDP.