If I still can't find that card before tomorow afternoon I think that's what I'm going to do since we have two more trips coming up and the current card expires end of July I believe.
Now I just need to find the Tylenol PM so I can sleep on this redeye flight hahaha - me sleep going to WDW -not a chance
Yes, we just renewed our TiW card and the person taking care of us specifically told us NOT to lose our card or we'd have to pay to either get a new one or replace the lost one.
She did say they can replace annual passes for free, as they can look them up but no luck with TiW.
I agree with other posters - I'd just get a new one since yours was about to expire anyway. Hope you have a great trip!