TOny, let me rephrase that question. If you were a normal cruiser (under 5 times), which night would you choose? While my wife and I are going on our fourth cruise, our kids are only going on their second. My two girls have already indicated that they do not want to miss Animator's Palette (this came up when I suggested doing the Sunset Cruise in Key West).
For us, both formal nights should place us in Parrot Cay. I see formal wear fitting in better with Palos than Parrot Cay.