I've stayed at the Deluxe Resorts and I've also stayed at The All Stars as well as offsite. Never a moderate.
I voted for All Stars...I like the Mighty Ducks Section the best. I like the location, the Action and we have had better service than some of the more expensive resorts. We are do-it yourself kind of people though, not the pampered type!
We also like the price. When we stayed at WL for 14 nights/compared to All Stars prices that's a whole lot of $$.
Truthfully, we enjoyed each equally.
However, we do LOVE staying in a Disney Resort compared to offsite which we have done several times also.