It was our first cruise, so I have nothing to compare it to, but from my experience:
*the cruise was absolutely wonderful!
*the crew was fantastic--I've never experienced such consistently good, friendly, over-the-top service;
*the food, of course, was outstanding;
*the entertainment was top-notch;
*the ship was in beautiful condition;
*the DISers that we met were so great! and so were our table-mates;
*we spent most of our free time in the adults-only areas, and never encountered any obvious intrusions of kids;
*Brent is amazing! He's an energizer bunny, always involved in stuff, available to meet and chat, etc.
I read that some DISers had magnets stolen from their doors, but we didn't (we were on level 1, so probably no one comes down there). The malfunctioning stabilizers didn't cause us any distress, but I know some people were on Dramamine & wrist bands anyway, so hopefully that worked for them.
Jan