We ate there on our last trip and were disappointed. We had just come out of Muppets and it was pouring, so we went in to escape the rain. Maybe I just wasn't in the mood for Italian, but nothing looked that great. We were there at lunch time, and I thought the prices were quite high for lunch (just MHO - we typically do counter service for lunch).
We decided to split a salad and pizza. The server was visibly annoyed at our choice to split a meal and did not bring extra plates or anything. We had to ask for an additional plate for both the salad and pizza. Needless to say, he barely returned and never refilled our drinks. It was not that busy, so maybe he was mad that we didn't order two entrees.
Whatever the case, I was not impressed, and we will not be returning.