Mama Melrose or Coral Reef?

[GovieMom]

Two completely different restaurants I know, but would like people's opinions on which they'd prefer, if they could choose between the two. And I'm talking food, not atmosphere. Thanks!

 

[MHSweb79]

Our meal at Mama Melrose was horrible. Never been to Coral Reef.
For a more balanced view, go over to allears.net and check out the "rate & review" section. There are tons of reviews for every restaurant.

 

[Disney Crazy Debbie]

If you are a seafood person, fish, etc., you'll love Coral Reef. I have not done Mama's because I always thought it was a little over priced.

 

[MickeyNicki]

I say Coral Reef, I loved the pan seared grouper over the risotto...it was excellent!

 

[WriteDisney]

I personally like Coral Reef more then Mama Melrose. I thought the food was just better, the Tropical Fruit Mango Sorbet for dessert was very good.

 

[VegasMike21]

Coral Reef, I believe they have more variety there, and their desserts are way better.

 

[gingerfeathers]

Coral Reef, if only for the ambience!

 

[MariDisney]

We've never had a bad experience at Mama Melrose's. We've enjoyed the food and atmosphere. We've never had a good experience at Coral Reef and will not be going back after a number of experiences.

 

[Dawn68PA]

We have yet to go to Mama's but Coral Reef's food was fantastic! And we're a family of land lubbers, only one seafood dish in our 6 person party last November. Darn good mahi mahi that was....

 

[TJA]

Our food has always been great at Coral Reef.....and our food has always been awful at Mama's. Too bad because we really like the atmosphere at Mama's and we continue to try different entrees hoping to find something that we like.

 

[tinkgurl]

We love Mama Melrose! It's a must for us every trip. The food is always good and we always have nice CM's.

 

[KEMdisney]

We were just at both places in June. 100% Coral Reef!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[newfiegirl]

coral....great steaks