This is a great, great question. It's actually one of my favorites, because although we live in a very posh neighborhood, I'm really not into fancy things for the sake of being fancy. I find it too pretentious. I prefer experiences where you can truly be in the moment and connect. To me, that's what romance and enjoyment are all about. So with that in mind, I've been giving some thought to what you can do to make your trip extra special...
I definitely agree with the PP's -- take advantage of the nighttime entertainment. There is nothing more romantic than enjoying the glowing lights and music all over WDW.
What about taking a food tour through Epcot one night for dinner? Use your snack and QS credits and share a few different dishes, rather than sitting down and each getting your own meals? I find sharing food to be very romantic!
Definitely note it on all your dining and resort reservations, and wear your "Just Married" button!
Also, how about scheduling a non-park day or two so you can just relax by the pool and not feel rushed? Depending on where you are staying, you can take a boat ride to DTD, explore your resort, listen to live music, etc.
Save lots of momentos from your trip -- boarding passes, restaurant receipts, all the little stickers and cards you collect in the parks. Take lots of pictures from the moment you leave your house to the moment you arrive home. And then create a photo album/scrap book and give it to your wife on your first anniversary.
Order a surprised to be delivered to your room through
Amazon Prime. It doesn't have to be something huge -- it can be as simple as Minnie Mouse ears, cute WDW PJ's, or a beach towel for your pool -- but it will a fun surprise at real world, and not Disney World, prices.
Those are a few thoughts.
Have fun and congratulations!!!!