Le Cellier vs Monsieur Paul

[Cordy2424]

Hi Everyone!

We are working on our ADR wish list for our honeymoon in November. We have the DxDP and are trying to decide between Le Cellier or Monsieur Paul for a 2 credit dinner in Epcot.

Suggestions on which to choose - or another 2 credit at Epcot you'd suggest more than one of these?

(DxDP is already decided, so please no posts about which dining plan we chose.)

Thanks in advance everyone!

 

[JZCubed]

Hi Everyone!

We are working on our ADR wish list for our honeymoon in November. We have the DxDP and are trying to decide between Le Cellier or Monsieur Paul for a 2 credit dinner in Epcot.

Suggestions on which to choose - or another 2 credit at Epcot you'd suggest more than one of these?

(DxDP is already decided, so please no posts about which dining plan we chose.)

Thanks in advance everyone!

Congratulations!

Monsieur Paul.

 

[Cordy2424]

Congratulations!

Monsieur Paul.

Thank you!!! So far 1 - MP, 0 - LC!

 

[auntfrannie]

Definitely Monsieur Paul. Some items have an upcharge even with the DxDP.

 

[piccolopat]

Definitely Monsieur Paul. Although the food is good at Le Cellier, we stopped going there because the tables pack you in like sardines. You are inches from the next table and the low ceiling makes the room noisy. Monsieur Paul on the other hand is nicely spaced out, has wonderful food and is a much quieter atmosphere. We almost never see children there and the ones that come are usually well behaved (not like some downstairs in Le Chefs de France).

Congrats!

 

[smcabee]

We like both but for a Honeymoon def Monsieur Paul.

 

[Cordy2424]

Wow! Thanks everyone!! Definitely making this a landslide!!!

 

[happymommy]

Def Mr. Paul. Ate at Le Cellier once years ago, no one was impressed.

 

[DisneyWishes14]

Monsieur Paul, especially for a honeymoon! Le Cellier is fine. We've never had a bad meal there, but it's quite crowded and noisy and the food doesn't compare to MP. MP is very special. You check in in this small area and the escort you up the stairs to a very beautiful decorated, quiet, romantic restaurant. The food and service are fantastic.

 

[Princess Mulan]

Monsieur Paul, especially for a honeymoon! Le Cellier is fine. We've never had a bad meal there, but it's quite crowded and noisy and the food doesn't compare to MP. MP is very special. You check in in this small area and the escort you up the stairs to a very beautiful decorated, quiet, romantic restaurant. The food and service are fantastic.

I could not say it better!

Definitely M. Paul!

 

[crabbygal902]

Another vote for MP

 

[Pumbaa_]

Le cellier is never on my list

 

[gharter]

Monsieur Paul. An amazing dining experience and a great menu when we were there.
LeCellier is good, but its an average steak house with above average prices.

 

[wishicouldgomoreofte]

Another definately MP.

 

[DisneyArkie]

I’ve been to every signature besides MP. Le Cellier is our #2 out of all the others. Yatchmans is #1. We are steak people though so really depends on what you prefer. MP we will be eating at on our next trip in 2019! I don’t agree with others that say it’s an average steak. I’ve been to very high end steak houses all over and it’s not an “Outback” as other suggest. Get the Fillet on top of Rissoto!

 

[MickeyMinnieMom]

We like Le Cellier as well, but Monsieur Paul has better food.

 

[KenHutch]

For a honeymoon? M Paul hands down, Le Cellier has been a legend in its own mind for years now. The steaks are average there and I have not been overly impressed with the service there. Its to hit or miss.

 

[crabbygal902]

Le Cellier has been a legend in its own mind for years now.

A legend in its own mind! I love that. There is no way their steak dinners are worth the current $50+ price tag. It's gotten too big for its britches, as we say in the South.

The beef tenderloin at MP is a relative bargain at $44.