le cellier or Yachtsman for dinner?

[bound4wdw]

We are going to have extra dining left over after all the reservations we've made and we are wanting to try a signature restaurant. Has any one tried both of these and can say one is better than the other? It will be two adults and an 8 yr old DD.

 

[ParrottFamily]

I have eaten at both Le Cellier in 09 and at Yatchman just 2 weeks ago, both have great steaks and sides but I would have to give the edge to Yatchman. The filet at Yatchman was the best steak I've ever eaten and the white truffle Mac and cheese was incredible

 

[Tigger's ally]

I have eaten at both Le Cellier in 09 and at Yatchman just 2 weeks ago, both have great steaks and sides but I would have to give the edge to Yatchman. The filet at Yatchman was the best steak I've ever eaten and the white truffle Mac and cheese was incredible

Why oh Why did you have to mention the Truffles and Cheese before lunch. I packed a stinkin lunchmeat samwhich and you bring up the Truffles and Cheese? I dock you 50 Disney credits for that!

 

[wdwrich]

Yachtsman. In our experience, resort signatures beat the park signatures any day.

 

[Tigger's ally]

Oh, to me, while I did enjoy Le Cellier cheddar soup, the Steak at Yachtsman and the "side dish too unbelievably good to mention before lunch" more than made up for it. Yachtsman, no doubt.

 

[cjsquared]

I agree with PPs, Yachtsman is better.

 

[disneypanda11]

Agree with PP's- we've eaten at both and would put Yachtsman heads and shoulders above Le Cellier. If you're seafood lovers, I would highly recommend trying the shrimp cocktail at Yachtsman. They have a housemade cocktail sauce that I could drink with a straw!

 

[nilla]

Le Cellier was perhaps my favorite restaurant back when it was a one-DDP-credit meal. Now, not so much. It's not worth the two credits, IMO.

Haven't been to the Yachtsman, but I've heard great things about it. Personally, my favorite two-credit is Narcoossee's.

 

[crb60]

Definitely in the minority here, but we much more enjoyed our meals at Le Cellier compared to Yachtsman this past September.

We had the cheddar cheese soup, filet and strip steak at Le Cellier and we had the lobster bisque and split the porterhouse for two at Yachtsman. Definitely thought Le Cellier was better. Wouldn't hesitate to go back there, would hesitate to go back to Yachtsman.