Le Cellier or Maya Grill

[Montog]

My dad is torn between Le Cellier or Maya Grill. He wants a steak, but good variety. What do you think? We've already made up our wish list for all the other ADR's and we're down to this decision for our last one. We've never eater at either - we are a party of five (my folks, me, my two girls age 7 and 13 at time of travel). So far we're hoping for Bamas, Coral Reef, Marrekech (sp?), Ohanas and Momma Melrose. This will make up our last TS reservation. Thanks!

 

[vascubaguy]

My dad is torn between Le Cellier or Maya Grill. He wants a steak, but good variety. What do you think? We've already made up our wish list for all the other ADR's and we're down to this decision for our last one. We've never eater at either - we are a party of five (my folks, me, my two girls age 7 and 13 at time of travel). So far we're hoping for Bamas, Coral Reef, Marrekech (sp?), Ohanas and Momma Melrose. This will make up our last TS reservation. Thanks!

If you can get it, I say go for Le Cellier.

 

[budbeerlady]

All I can say is Cedder Cheese soup, ice wine martini and creme brulee... hands down Le Cellier!

 

[lovinwdw]

Definitely Le Cellier!!!!

 

[KatMark]

Definitely LeCellier. Although we've stayed at CSR and it is our "home away from home", we've only had breakfast once at Maya Grill and never dinner. Maya gets a mixed bag of reviews.

 

[tinkgurl]

I'd go with Le Cellier!

 

[RJS]

Based on DISboard advice on steaks, we are trying the Yachtsman this time for a dinner, as well as a Le Cellier lunch. Looking forward to both!

 

[SweetSerenity]

Another vote for Le Cellier

 

[chocovrdmicears]

Oh my...without a doubt...LeCellier...

You could have said "Pizza Planet" or " Maya Grill" and I would have picked Pizza Planet.

 

[Crystal824]

Le Cellier if you can get it. I called 90 days out and couldn't get it. Granted I only tried for 3 days not everyday, but it was unavaliable all day for those 3 days.

As for Maya Grill, I've only had breakfast there, but it was pretty good.

 

[GSDRescuer]

I loved my filet mignon at Maya Grill!!!

 

[Montog]

Wow! Thank you for all the responses, from the looks of it, sounds like everyone agrees on le cellier, but mixed reviews on Maya so easy to pick the safer bet. Thanks!!

 

[pavil]

I have eaten at Maya Grill, it's pretty good food in my book, I had the steak. Le Cellier I haven't eaten at but I would go there in a heartbeat given the choice between the two. It gets too many rave reviews for everyone to be wrong. Go to Le Cellier.

 

[aubriee]

Le Cellier is probably the most coveted ADR at WDW. If you are lucky enough to get one for dinner, grab it. Call at exactly 0700 Eastern time and make sure the first ADR you ask for is Le Cellier for any night that week.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

LC is very hard to get into. So if you can't get in there Maya Grill is Very Good in my opinion.

 

[The 'Mickster']

Haven't tried Maya but Le Cellier never disappoints.....unless you've been raised with the silver spoon (just kidding)!!!