Thanks for the additional info, Rusty. When you stay at the Peabody, do they make YOU call housekeeping or does the front desk call and check for you?
Somehow, the picture of a guest at the Peabody making that call is laughable. Disney, by contrast, makes the guest call housekeeping, which is always a hopeless exercise, IMO.
I stay at Hyatts and Hiltons and have not run into a situation where housekeeping makes the decision. I also haven't experienced that at Marriotts. Haven't stayed at the Orlando or Memphis Peabody, so can't speak to that.
And, just wondering -- when you say housekeeping has always decided, how many years are you speaking of? Disney hotels have been there since the 70s. I still think it's a relatively new phenomenon that housekeeping is in charge of who gets late checkout.
For example, according to Disney, it's not housekeeping that has decided DVC guests never get late checkout. Disney always says that it is "DVC Owners" who have made the decision about no late checkout. So, who has really made the decision? They didn't send out ballots to all DVC members, contrary to their assertion it was DVC owners. Housekeeping may have weighed in, but the final decision has to have been made by senior hotel management (or even higher up at senior DVC management).
I think it's a cop-out for hotel management to blame the decision on housekeeping. It's a way to shift the blame by saying, "hey, not our fault, please come again." It's easy for hotel management to say, "we're not in charge -- housekeeping is." Right.
For a recent club level stay, we called housekeeping and asked for late checkout and were told no -- emaphatically no. We went to the concierge, she checked for us and was told yes. The number of housekeepers, the number of absences, the number of rooms to be cleaned, the number of guests checking in, etc., could not have changed in the five minutes it took us to walk from the phone in our room to the concierge desk. So, clearly special consideration was given to us as club level guests who paid a lot of money for our stay. The decision is highly subjective. Even if the final decision is made by housekeeping -- they can be "persuaded". Our personal experience proves that.
Whatever. As I said, for our stay a few months ago, we booked an extra night. Expensive, but far less frustrating than negotiating with the inmates about the rules "they" have supposedly made for the asylum.