Ladies, which shoe...

[Aurora63]

Go with #2. A pointy toe helps to elongate your legs (always a good thing.)

 

[betsywdw]

I love #2! I really like a the pointed toe. I think it would look great with nice dress pants.

 

[lillygator]

no offense but pointy toe = witch to me...(I have only one pointy toe heeled shoe) - worn once....I don't know why I think this!!!....must have been some bad movie my mother subjected me to.

 

[alliecats]

This would be my first pointy-toe pair, because I have never liked them 'til now. I think I will compromise and stick with a lower-heeled (like 2.5 inches instead of 3.5!), rounded-toe pair with skirts, and then these higher pointy-toes with pants. Then it won't matter how high the heel is because they won't look as dramatic as with a skirt, if that makes sense.
Thanks to everyone for your input!!

 

[PrincessAuroraInPA]

I vote for #2!

 

[craps7or11]

Shoe number 2.

 

[blueroses]

I think the rounded toe is too casual for business attire, but I work in software where we're lucky when some people even wear shoes AT ALL so what do I know?

I personally don't wear anything with a pointy toe because my size 9.5s look quite long enough as it is (I also will not wear a white shoe, not even a sneaker).

 

[lovetoscrap]

My feet hurt just looking at those choices!

 

[Blondie]

Shoe # 1 looks more comfortable, but all I see around town now are the pointy toes.

I'd probably go with #1 and wish I bought the second ones after the fact!

 

[bengalbelle]

This would be my first pointy-toe pair, because I have never liked them 'til now. I think I will compromise and stick with a lower-heeled (like 2.5 inches instead of 3.5!), rounded-toe pair with skirts, and then these higher pointy-toes with pants. Then it won't matter how high the heel is because they won't look as dramatic as with a skirt, if that makes sense.
Thanks to everyone for your input!!

That's my girl! Buy them both

FTR, I like the rounded toe. I have a similar pair in brown, but with a chunkier heel.

 

[alliecats]

That's my girl! Buy them both

FTR, I like the rounded toe. I have a similar pair in brown, but with a chunkier heel.

Ahhh, you did have your little girl!!! She is beautiful! I already knew Christopher was gorgeous.
What did you name her????

 

[Disney Doll]

They are both very pretty. I like shoe #1 because of the toe portion. I don't care for the pointy toes on shoe #2.

I agree

 

[Miss Jasmine]

I like the second one, but in a lower heel. Heels that high aren't appropriate for most business environments, IMHO. It sends a message you may not want to be sending.

Oh please. A couple pairs of my business shoes have 3 inch heels. Believe me, they don't send "that" message. That is such a silly thing to worry about.

I like #1. Though I have a pair like #2 but in brown and I LOVE them. So I say either is a good choice.

 

[bengalbelle]

Ahhh, you did have your little girl!!! She is beautiful! I already knew Christopher was gorgeous.
What did you name her????

Thank you. When I get her settled down later I'll PM you with all of the details.

 

[dreamcometrue]

I like #1 better, however #2 is a bit more formal!

 

[lajones81]

Shoe #1

 

[dolphinrescuegirl]

I also like shoe#1. The pointy ones remind me of a witch.