Ladies, need eye liner help!

[Barb A.]

Anyone know of a good, waterproof, smudgeproof, everything proof pencil type eye liner? I just can't seem to find one that works really good!! Thanks.

 

[Christine]

My favorite is the Lancome Kohl pencil. Sometimes when I run out and I can't get to the department store, I've tried some of the cheaper brands and I've really had a problem with them. They smear off, smudge, or they don't go on well at all. Right now I am using one by Mary Kay that is not too bad.

 

[Barb A.]

Christine, can you tell me what the Mary Kay one is called? Thanks

 

[Alice28]

I'm a Clinique lover myself. Goes on smoothly and stays on all day.

 

[Christine]

Barb,
It's called Mary Kay Signature Eyeliner (I use the color "Steely"). Claims to be smudgeproof. So far it is. It costs $9.50 and you don't need to sharpen it.

 

[BedKnobbery2]

The absolute best eye-liner solution I've ever found is a product by Too-Faced (can't remember the name of the product, but that's the manufacturer) that is a wand in a little tube of clear liquid that turns any eye shadow into an eyeliner. You take out the wand, dab it in the shadow, and apply just like any liquid eye-liner. You just need to be sure to wipe the wand off before putting it back in the tube. It is totally smudge-proof, tear-proof, water-proof, everything-proof. I love this stuff.

However, you specifically asked about pencil type liners.....in that case, the best I've found is Christian Dior, which I get at Sephora. Pricey, but works quite well. (But not as well as the above-mentioned product!)

 

[gemmie214]

I love anything by Guerlain. The products are long lasting and work very well for sensitive skin.